LegalNewsLine Logo  
Saturday, July 4 2009     Subscribe in NewsGator Online
News | Contact LegalNewsline | About Us | Advertise | RSS
Enter search keyword
 
NEWSLETTER
Receive our FREE weekly newsletter
click here
LNL MOST POPULAR ARTICLES
+ U.S. Supreme Court sides with white firefighters in race bias case
+ U.S. Supreme Court: State AGs may probe national lending practices
+ King: Rethink GM bankruptcy plan
+ McKenna argues against federal preemption of consumer laws
+ Obama says Supreme Court 'moving the ball' on affirmative action
LNL HOT TOPICS
+ Asbestos
+ Bankruptcy
+ Big Pharma
+ Class Action
+ Dickie Scruggs
+ Financial Crisis
+ Gasoline Prices
+ Global Warming
+ Hurricane Katrina
+ Lead Paint
+ Personal Injury
+ Sub-Prime Mortgages
State Supreme Courts 
 
Lead paint lawsuit tide follows landmark Supreme Court ruling
Justice Louis B. Butler
Justice Annette Ziegler
MADISON -- Last month's Wisconsin Supreme Court election that replaced Jon P. Wilcox with controversial fellow-conservative Annette Ziegler is rumored to have cost over $6 million.

But that could be proverbial chicken feed compared to the amount at stake over some high profile and potentially lucrative lead paint lawsuits that have recently shifted to federal courts in Wisconsin.

Four of the cases involve children suing former lead paint manufacturers for health damages. One landmark case in 2005 set the stage for most other suits, yesterday's Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (MJS) reported.

A separate $85 million case by the City of Milwaukee against lead paint companies will go to trial this month, a first for the state, MJS noted. The city has filed a public nuisance lawsuit to force two paint makers to pay for lead paint clean-ups in city buildings.

The Milwaukee lawsuit strongly resembles a case outlined recently in LegalNewsLine that's currently before the Missouri Supreme Court. It was brought by the City of St Louis against six lead paint manufacturers, including Milwaukee pair NL Holdings and Sherwin-Williams, for city clean-up fees.

Paint manufacturers have already appealed to the Rhode Island Supreme Court over last year's decision against them estimated at over $1 billion. A lower court ordered three paint-makers to pay for removing lead paint from contaminated buildings in the state.

The lead paint lawsuit push suffered a setback last month in a California Superior Court, LegalNewsLine reported, when state-paid contingency fees were knocked down. Undaunted, Ohio Attorney General Mark Dann filed a public-nuisance lawsuit against 10 paint companies a few days later over objections from GOP lawmakers.

Wisconsin's four child-based cases were moved from state to federal court over the past month because there were no local defendants, the children's attorney, Peter Earle, told MSJ. The cases involve adults exposed to lead paint as children living in Milwaukee homes.

Earle has 31 similar cases awaiting trial in Wisconsin, including one that led to a key Supreme Court ruling in what's known as the Steven Thomas case.

There the Supreme Court decided, in a contentious two-dissent ruling, that plaintiffs could sue without identifying a specific paint-maker. In doing so it controversially accepted the "risk contribution" theory of liability proposed by Steven Thomas's attorneys.

"We also conclude that the white lead carbonate claims at issue in this case...warrant extension of the risk-contribution theory," wrote Justice Louis B. Butler for the majority opinion.

This ruling overturned an earlier Wisconsin Court of Appeals ruling that itself had affirmed a trial court ruling. Those rulings both dismissed the "risk contribution" theory as not relevant to the case.

Defendants in that case were American Cyanamid, Atlantic Richfield, E.I. DuPont, NL Industries, SCM Chemicals, Sherwin-Williams and ConAgra Grocery Products. Two - NL Industries and Sherwin Willimas - are defending lead paint suits in all five states they've been filed in.

Milwaukee officials claim lead poisoning levels in the city's children is six times the national average because of the large number of older houses. Like most states, Wisconsin banned lead paint use in 1978.

Filed Under: State Supreme Courts


COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:

No comments have been posted in the last 15 days!

SEND US YOUR COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:


* - Required fields

Subject: *
Message: *
Contact Name: *
Contact URL:
Contact Email: *
This Is CAPTCHA Image
Write the characters in the image above: 

E-mail this article to a friend | Printer friendly format

MORE NEWS HEADLINES:
+ Ohio justices to hear satellite TV tax case - 7/1  
+ Minn. Supreme Court: Al Franken won Minnesota Senate race - 7/1  
+ Nevada SC approves rules for new foreclosure mediation program - 6/30  
+ N.J. Senate gives justice tenure - 6/29  
+ Civil justice group says 'right decision, wrong author' in court'... - 6/24  
+ Arizona Supreme Court sidesteps budget battle - 6/24  
+ Justice Albin one step closer to tenure - 6/23  
+ Sheetz unhappy with Pa. SC decision - 6/16  
+ Utah SC hears DRAM price-fixing case - 6/13  
+ Calif. court: Businesses may be sued for unintentional ADA violat... - 6/12  


IN THE SPOTLIGHT:
Monday, June 29, 2009
WASHNGTON (Legal Newsline) - The federal government plans to withhold nearly a half-million dollars the next time it doles out Medicaid funding to the State of West Virginia as a result of a settlement engineered by state Attorney General Darrell McGraw.
Read more...


+ The Libby verdict: Did the judge play favorites? - 6/2
+ Sotomayor can expect plenty of scrutiny - 5/26
+ The Libby verdict: Prosecutors make a fatal mistake - 5/21
+ California judge accuses asbestos firms of playing 'grisly games' - 5/5
+ GOP calls for outside counsel reform in wake of Rendell controversy - 4/23
BROWSE BY STATE:
 
BROWSE BY AG:
 
BROWSE BY DATE:
 
LATEST LNL BLOG ENTRIES:
+ Abbott: Beware Dietary Supplement Scams and 'Miracle' Health Claims
+ Abbott's signs of a scam
+ AG McCollum on convicts in the mortgage industry
NEWS WIDGET:
Attention bloggers:
Add Record Headlines to your site!


fast + free- click here

NEWS | CONTACT LEGALNEWSLINE | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | RSS © 2008 LegalNewsLine.com. All Rights Reserved.