LegalNewsLine Logo  
Saturday, July 4 2009     Subscribe in NewsGator Online
News | Contact LegalNewsline | About Us | Advertise | RSS
Enter search keyword
 
NEWSLETTER
Receive our FREE weekly newsletter
click here
LNL MOST POPULAR ARTICLES
+ U.S. Supreme Court sides with white firefighters in race bias case
+ U.S. Supreme Court: State AGs may probe national lending practices
+ King: Rethink GM bankruptcy plan
+ Obama says Supreme Court 'moving the ball' on affirmative action
+ McKenna argues against federal preemption of consumer laws
LNL HOT TOPICS
+ Asbestos
+ Bankruptcy
+ Big Pharma
+ Class Action
+ Dickie Scruggs
+ Financial Crisis
+ Gasoline Prices
+ Global Warming
+ Hurricane Katrina
+ Lead Paint
+ Personal Injury
+ Sub-Prime Mortgages
State AGs 
 
Alaska's settlement with Eli Lilly is a tax on healthcare, says critic
Talis Colberg
ANCHORAGE - Alaska Attorney General Talis Colberg has reached a $15 million settlement with pharmaceutical giant Eli Lilly and Co., over claims that the pharmaceutical company systematically downplayed the risks associated with its schizophrenia drug Zyprexa.

In what is the first Zyprexa-related lawsuit to reach a jury trial, Alaska officials were seeking $270 million in damages under the Alaska Unfair Trade Practice Consumer Protection Act for costs that the state said it would incur from health problems that its Medicaid patients could develop from using the widely used psychiatric medication.

The case was watched closely by other states, including Pennsylvania and Connecticut, and by federal prosecutors that are considering similar actions against Eli Lilly.

In ongoing mediation ordered by Anchorage Superior Court Judge Mark Rindner, the Indianapolis-based drugmaker agreed to pay the state $15 million plus a term that will ensure that Alaska is treated as favorably as any other state that may settle with Lilly in the future over similar claims.

The settlement agreement, announced Wednesday, involves no admission of wrongdoing on Eli Lilly's part.

Attorneys for the state had claimed that Lilly failed to warn patients and the state of health problems linked to Zyprexa, including diabetes and obesity, among other side effects. The state also contended that Lilly broke federal regulations by marketing the drug for unapproved uses in children with hyperactivity disorder and elderly patients with dementia.

James Beck, an attorney and medical liability expert in the Philadelphia law office of Dechert LLP, said Wednesday that the Alaska attorney general was pursuing a matter best left to federal regulators.

Beck said, so-called "off label" use, where a drug is used for an unapproved purpose, is generally within the medical standard of care that is "designed to help people."

He said the state was trying to assess liability for drugs that were prescribed for "therapeutically appropriate," off-label use that helped patients recover from mental illness.

"This litigation made no logical sense; it was brought purely to recover as much money as they can for things even when nobody did anything wrong," said Beck, who wrote the Drug and Medical Device Product Liability Handbook.

States, he said, are pursing these types of regulatory cases in order to generate revenue simply because state lawmakers are "afraid" to raise taxes.

"This is an attempt to put in a tax without having the legislature approve it," Beck said. "If you divorce this from any sense of legal wrongdoing then you are simply taxing the healthcare system in another name."

Throughout the trial that began March 3, Lilly maintained that it had not broken the law, and said it stood behind the medication that was considered a breakthrough in the treatment of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder when it was introduced in 1996.

Robert Armitage, Lilly's senior vice president and general counsel, said in a statement Wednesday that while the drug company had a "strong defense," reaching an "amicable resolution" was in the best interest of Lilly and the state.

"A trial always involves significant time and resources, especially a two-phase trial like this one that posed additional legal hurdles," he said. "A settlement helps us get back to what we want to focus on as a company: developing important new medications through research and partnerships with doctors and patients."

Zyprexa, which is among the third-best-selling antipsychotic in the United States, had worldwide sales last year of $4.76 billion.

Patrick Burns, communications director of Taxpayers Against Fraud, a Washington, D.C. group that monitors government anti-fraud actions, said the Alaska lawsuit will likely prove to be less significant than lawsuits against Eli that are sure to follow.

"There is almost a perfect storm of litigation for everything from stockholder suits to patients who have medical fallout, to off-label marketing to state liability issues," Burns said. "It's just like a clown car of litigation; it's just going to keep unbundling."

The case is Alaska v. Eli Lilly & Co., 3AN-06-05630 CI, Alaska Superior Court in Anchorage.


Filed Under: State AGs


COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:

No comments have been posted in the last 15 days!

SEND US YOUR COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:


* - Required fields

Subject: *
Message: *
Contact Name: *
Contact URL:
Contact Email: *
This Is CAPTCHA Image
Write the characters in the image above: 

E-mail this article to a friend | Printer friendly format

MORE NEWS HEADLINES:
+ Five lead plaintiffs named in Bank of America class action - 7/3  
+ States join FTC in targeting business opportunity fraud - 7/3  
+ State AGs reach tentative agreement with General Motors - 7/2  
+ Another agrees to Cuomo's pension fund reform - 7/2  
+ Poultry producers seek to delay trial - 7/2  
+ Hawaii governor vetoes online tax bill - 7/2  
+ Mich. AG opposes Blue Cross Blue Shield rate increase - 7/2  
+ Blumenthal: DPUC agrees to cuts - 7/2  
+ Arbitrator says Nebraska owes Kansas $10k for water usage - 7/2  
+ N.J. reaches settlement with seventh moving and storage company t... - 7/2  


IN THE SPOTLIGHT:
Monday, June 29, 2009
WASHNGTON (Legal Newsline) - The federal government plans to withhold nearly a half-million dollars the next time it doles out Medicaid funding to the State of West Virginia as a result of a settlement engineered by state Attorney General Darrell McGraw.
Read more...


+ The Libby verdict: Did the judge play favorites? - 6/2
+ Sotomayor can expect plenty of scrutiny - 5/26
+ The Libby verdict: Prosecutors make a fatal mistake - 5/21
+ California judge accuses asbestos firms of playing 'grisly games' - 5/5
+ GOP calls for outside counsel reform in wake of Rendell controversy - 4/23
BROWSE BY STATE:
 
BROWSE BY AG:
 
BROWSE BY DATE:
 
LATEST LNL BLOG ENTRIES:
+ Abbott: Beware Dietary Supplement Scams and 'Miracle' Health Claims
+ Abbott's signs of a scam
+ AG McCollum on convicts in the mortgage industry
NEWS WIDGET:
Attention bloggers:
Add Record Headlines to your site!


fast + free- click here

NEWS | CONTACT LEGALNEWSLINE | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | RSS © 2008 LegalNewsLine.com. All Rights Reserved.