LegalNewsLine Logo  
Tuesday, May 22 2012 Twitter  feedburner  yahoo  Subscribe in NewsGator Online
News | Contact LegalNewsline | About Us | Advertise | RSS
Enter search keyword
 
clear
clear
NEWSLETTER
Receive our FREE weekly newsletter
click here
Today's Offers:

LNL MOST POPULAR ARTICLES
+ Ind. AG files lawsuits against home loan modification companies
+ Mich. SC justice under scrutiny for real estate transactions
+ Verizon employee settles with employer, union
+ Seventh Circuit slams door on shareholder lawsuit against Zimmer
+ SEC charges N.J. man with real estate investment scam
LNL HOT TOPICS
+ Asbestos
+ Big Pharma
+ BP Oil Spill
+ Class Action
+ Dickie Scruggs
+ Federal Government
+ Financial Crisis
+ Global Warming
+ Hurricane Katrina
+ Labor Issues
+ Lead Paint
+ Sub-Prime Mortgages
U.S. District Court 
story date  
U.S. Supreme Court seemingly the next stop for ObamaCare
obama.jpg
Obama
WASHINGTON (Legal Newsline) - The federal government apparently won't delay the legal battle over health care reform.

A Department of Justice spokesperson told the Wall Street Journal Monday that the DOJ will not ask the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit to reconsider its August decision that found a portion of the reform package unconstitutional.

The 11th Circuit, one of many appeals courts to rule on the issue, said the $695 annual penalty assessed to individuals who do not purchase health care is unconstitutional. That ruling came in a lawsuit brought by 26 states and the National Federation for Independent Business.

"NFIB is excited that all indications point to the government going directly to the Supreme Court to hear our case and commends the Administration on their decision," said Karen Harned, the executive director of NFIB's Business Legal Center.

"The uncertainty created by the healthcare law on small businesses and other job creators is an immeasurable and burdensome effect on the economy. We are hopeful that the Supreme Court will take our case immediately."

The 11th Circuit's decision was reached by a three-judge panel. The federal government had the option to ask that the case be heard by the entire roster of judges.

Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli had attempted to bypass the Fourth Circuit and take his challenge straight to the Supreme Court but he was not successful. The Fourth Circuit recently ruled he lacked standing to challenge the mandate.

The Third Circuit ruled in August that a group of New Jersey physicians did not have standing to challenge the law. The Sixth Circuit ruled 2-1 in June for Obama, and the 11th Circuit's decision affirmed an earlier one by U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson, of Florida.

Eleventh Circuit Chief Judge Joel Dubina authored its opinion and was joined by Judge Frank Hull in the majority. Judge Stanley Marcus voted against the states.

"The individual mandate exceeds Congress's enumerated commerce power and is unconstitutional," Dubina wrote. "This economic mandate represents a wholly novel and potentially unbounded assertion of congressional authority: the ability to compel Americans to purchase an expensive health insurance product they have elected not to buy, and to make them re-purchase that insurance product every month for their entire lives."

In January, Vinson found that Congress was unconstitutionally regulating economic inactivity and, because the mandate is too integral a part to be separated, he voided the entire legislation. He called it "a difficult decision to reach."

The 11th Circuit's decision, though, did not void the entire legislation.

"Excising the individual mandate from the Act does not prevent the remaining provisions from being 'fully operative as a law,'" Dubina wrote.

From Legal Newsline: Reach John O'Brien by e-mail at jobrienwv@gmail.com.

Filed Under: U.S. District Court

E-mail this article to a friend | Printer friendly format

MORE NEWS HEADLINES:
+ Seventh Circuit sides with Ill. governor on pay raises - 5/22   read more
+ Suit over soda's formula points to problems in W.Va. legal system - 5/17   read more
+ Verizon employee settles with employer, union - 5/17   read more
+ Federal judge refuses to dismiss Chevron RICO lawsuit - 5/16   read more
+ Fourth Circuit rules for Time Warner in dispute with MASN - 5/16   read more
+ Seventh Circuit: Bill collector can be sued for calls to wrong nu... - 5/15   read more
+ Sixth Circuit: Other companies can be held liable in beam acciden... - 5/15   read more
+ Second Circuit rules against NLRB in Starbucks case - 5/14   read more
+ Two stock promoters, trader and lawyer sentenced in scheme - 5/14   read more
+ Three N.Y. union leaders guilty of racketeering, extortion - 5/14   read more


IN THE SPOTLIGHT:
livermore.jpg
Monday, May 21, 2012
NEW YORK (Legal Newsline) - A think tank affiliated with New York University School of Law has issued a report that "takes aim at the confusing debate over jobs and environmental regulation."
Read more...


+ Controversial presentation on creating 'legacy lawsuits' uncovered - 5/11
+ Defendants mount arguments for keeping Colossus in federal court - 5/8
+ Alaska AG says EPA's actions 'unlawful' - 4/30
+ U.S. SC won't take on torture case against Chevron - 4/27
+ Judge in Ark. Colossus class action did not 'play' - 4/25
BROWSE BY STATE:
 
BROWSE BY AG:
 
BROWSE BY DATE:
 
NEWS WIDGET:
Attention bloggers:
Add Record Headlines to your site!


fast + free- click here
NEWS | CONTACT LEGALNEWSLINE | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | RSS © 2008 LegalNewsLine.com. All Rights Reserved.