LegalNewsLine Logo  
Wednesday, May 23 2012 Twitter  feedburner  yahoo  Subscribe in NewsGator Online
News | Contact LegalNewsline | About Us | Advertise | RSS
Enter search keyword
 
clear
clear
NEWSLETTER
Receive our FREE weekly newsletter
click here
Today's Offers:

LNL MOST POPULAR ARTICLES
+ Seventh Circuit slams door on shareholder lawsuit against Zimmer
+ Mich. SC justice under scrutiny for real estate transactions
+ Verizon employee settles with employer, union
+ SEC charges N.J. man with real estate investment scam
+ NYU report: Environmental jobs claims often made 'out of context'
LNL HOT TOPICS
+ Asbestos
+ Big Pharma
+ BP Oil Spill
+ Class Action
+ Dickie Scruggs
+ Federal Government
+ Financial Crisis
+ Global Warming
+ Hurricane Katrina
+ Labor Issues
+ Lead Paint
+ Sub-Prime Mortgages
State Supreme Courts 
story date  
Conn. SC rules in favor of insurer in carbon monoxide case
richardpalmer.jpg
Palmer
HARTFORD, Conn. (Legal Newsline) - The Connecticut Supreme Court has ruled in favor of an insurance company in a case over whether a homeowner's policy would cover carbon monoxide-related injuries.

Two medical students, Armenui Dzhgalian and Aida Melikyan, traveled to Connecticut in 2007 to participate in a month-long, unpaid internship at Griffin Hospital in Derby, Conn.

During their internships, they lived with defendant Maria V. Nantes, a hospital employee, at her home in Ansonia, Conn.

The two students suffered serious injuries after Nantes left her car running overnight in an attached garage, filling the house with carbon monoxide.

At issue is whether the students' injuries are covered by Nantes' homeowners insurance policy, issued by plaintiff New London County Mutual Insurance Co.

The insurer sued Nantes, the two medical students and Nantes' car insurer, Government Employees Insurance Co., seeking a declaration that Nantes' homeowners policy does not cover the students' injuries.

New London, which argues that its policy excludes coverage for injuries "arising out of the use of" a motor vehicle, filed a motion for summary judgment.

The trial court granted its motion and rendered judgment for the plaintiff. The defendants appealed.

The state's high court, in an opinion that will be officially released Tuesday, affirmed the lower court's ruling.

Justice Richard N. Palmer wrote the Court's opinion.

The justice said it boils down to Nantes' act of leaving her car running in the garage.

"The defendants claim, rather, that leaving a car in one's garage does not constitute the use of a motor vehicle. We disagree," he wrote.

"When Nantes drove into the garage, exited the car and left it there upon entering the house, she was parking the car. Parking is plainly an employment of a car for some purpose of the user.

"Moreover, the act of parking does not fail to be an employment of a car for some purpose of the user merely because the user performs the act negligently, as Nantes did by exiting the car without turning it off."

The defendants also argued that because a "concurrent" cause of the students' injuries was Nantes' act of closing the garage door -- and because that act is covered under the policy -- the injuries should, too, be covered.

The Court deemed the covered event "irrelevant," citing past case law.

From Legal Newsline: Reach Jessica Karmasek by email at jessica@legalnewsline.com.

Filed Under: State Supreme Courts

E-mail this article to a friend | Printer friendly format

MORE NEWS HEADLINES:
+ Mich. trial lawyers group awarded SC justice ahead of allegations - 5/22   read more
+ Pa. SC justice's sister resigns ahead of corruption sentencing - 5/21   read more
+ Five Kan. SC justices step aside in Kline disciplinary case - 5/21   read more
+ Pa. SC justice Melvin suspended amid pending charges - 5/18   read more
+ W.Va. SC says court right not to remove juror in personal injury ... - 5/17   read more
+ Mich. judicial commission won't comment on Hathaway allegations - 5/17   read more
+ Mich. SC justice under scrutiny for real estate transactions - 5/16   read more
+ Dickson selected as head of Ind. high court - 5/16   read more
+ Kan. SC: Retail price maintenance illegal under state law - 5/15   read more
+ Conn. SC: Employer liable for sexual harassment - 5/14   read more


IN THE SPOTLIGHT:
livermore.jpg
Monday, May 21, 2012
NEW YORK (Legal Newsline) - A think tank affiliated with New York University School of Law has issued a report that "takes aim at the confusing debate over jobs and environmental regulation."
Read more...


+ Controversial presentation on creating 'legacy lawsuits' uncovered - 5/11
+ Defendants mount arguments for keeping Colossus in federal court - 5/8
+ Alaska AG says EPA's actions 'unlawful' - 4/30
+ U.S. SC won't take on torture case against Chevron - 4/27
+ Judge in Ark. Colossus class action did not 'play' - 4/25
BROWSE BY STATE:
 
BROWSE BY AG:
 
BROWSE BY DATE:
 
NEWS WIDGET:
Attention bloggers:
Add Record Headlines to your site!


fast + free- click here
NEWS | CONTACT LEGALNEWSLINE | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | RSS © 2008 LegalNewsLine.com. All Rights Reserved.