Ginger Harrelson is co-founder and chief legal officer of Beachball Properties, and she is also a member of the Orange Beach City Council.
ORANGE BEACH, Ala. – An Orange Beach councilwoman who co-owns a vacation rental management company is advocating new requirements for the industry her business serves, putting her private financial interests and public responsibilities at the center of a debate over guest safety and the burdens facing independent rental owners.
Councilwoman Ginger Harrelson, an attorney and co-founder of Beachball Properties, has publicly challenged Airbnb’s restrictions on guest information and rental agreements. Her company also issued a release urging local officials to adopt requirements for short-term rentals, according to published reports.
Beachball Properties has a significant presence in the Orange Beach rental market. The company could see substantial profits if Harrelson’s proposal passes.
The company’s website displays nearly 150 Orange Beach rental listings. If the company added 30 properties, those contracts could generate nearly $400,000 in additional annual management revenue, assuming each property produces $50,000 to $75,000 in annual base rent and pays the company’s advertised 18% commission.
The City Council is expected to consider an ordinance November 17 requiring guest identification, signed rental agreements and emergency contact information, according to AL.com. Airbnb has questioned the need for additional requirements and called for any council member with a conflict of interest to recuse themselves, without identifying a particular official.
Harrelson’s campaign website says she helped build Beachball Properties into a business managing more than 350 vacation rentals along the Gulf Coast. Her participation in the debate raises questions about how she will separate her role in shaping regulations from her ownership of a company operating under them. The available reporting does not establish an ethics violation or quantify any financial benefit she might receive.
The proposal also presents practical questions for property owners who manage their own rentals: what information they must collect, how they must protect it and whether they can meet the requirements without hiring outside help. Airbnb argues the changes could place disproportionate burdens on occasional hosts, while local property managers say the information and agreements are necessary safeguards.
The available reporting does not establish that the ordinance would require owners to hire a licensed real estate professional or prevent them from independently listing properties on Airbnb or Vrbo. Those claims should not be treated as established consequences of the proposal without confirmation in the complete ordinance language.
Harrelson’s role in the debate
Harrelson raised concerns about Airbnb’s policies during the council’s November 3 meeting, according to AL.com. She said rental operators need signed agreements and information about the people staying in their properties, including the ability to conduct background checks.
“Property managers have been able to have rental agreements to know who is in their properties, and to do background checks,” Harrelson said, according to the publication.
Beachball Properties’ release sought local requirements for guest identification, signed rental agreements and emergency contact information regardless of the platform used to book a stay, according to South AL News.
Harrelson’s campaign website identifies her as a co-founder of the company and a former municipal attorney for Orange Beach. Her legal background and business ownership place her in a position to understand both the regulatory process and the operational concerns of vacation rental managers. They also make her financial connection to the proposed rules relevant to the public debate.
Harrelson declined to comment for AL.com’s November 15 report. That report did not establish whether she planned to participate in a vote or recuse herself.
Public office and private interests
Alabama’s ethics law prohibits public officials from using their positions to obtain unauthorized personal gain for themselves, family members or businesses with which they are associated. Its definition of a conflict of interest also considers whether official action would materially affect an official’s financial interests differently from those of other members of the same class.
Owning a business subject to regulation does not, by itself, establish that an official has violated the law. Evaluating a particular situation requires examining the official’s participation, the action under consideration and the financial interests affected.
The overlap between Harrelson’s business interests and council responsibilities therefore presents questions distinct from whether the ordinance is sound policy. The sources reviewed for this story do not establish that she improperly used her office or received a financial benefit from the proposal.
Airbnb’s call for officials with conflicts to step aside adds another point of contention to an already public disagreement between the booking platform and local rental managers.
Disagreement over guest protections
Local property managers say signed agreements and access to guest information help protect properties, respond to emergencies and address misconduct. Airbnb disputes the suggestion that its policies leave hosts without adequate safeguards.
The company says booking guests undergo identity verification and that its terms of service and hosts’ house rules already govern reservations. Requiring separate agreements could duplicate those protections and create uncertainty about which conditions apply, Airbnb said.
Airbnb also said hosts may check identification at arrival when the requirement is disclosed before booking. Additional collection of personal information is permitted when required by law or homeowner association rules, the company said.
That exception helps explain the push for municipal action: A city requirement could provide a basis for collecting information or requiring agreements that the platform otherwise restricts. Airbnb’s updated policies are scheduled to take effect November 20.
Orange Beach’s proposal, released November 13, also would limit overnight occupancy to one person per 200 square feet of residential living space and require an owner to respond within one hour to a city complaint about problems at a property. A first violation would carry a $500 fine, with subsequent violations potentially leading to revocation of a business license.
City Administrator Ford Handley described the proposal as a safety measure.
“As a coastal city, safety is a number one priority for our residents and guests visiting here on vacation,” he told AL.com.
Stakes for independent owners
For owners who manage their own rentals, the proposed requirements raise questions about preparing agreements, handling sensitive information and responding to complaints.
Airbnb says nearly 80% of its Alabama hosts occasionally rent out just one home. The company argued that the proposed rules would make those hosts responsible for drafting contracts and securely collecting and storing personal information. The figure applies statewide, not specifically to Orange Beach.
The dispute is therefore not simply about whether guests should be identifiable. It also concerns who collects their information, what additional documentation is necessary and whether those responsibilities are manageable for owners without a professional management staff.
Orange Beach already requires rental property owners to obtain a business license even when a management company handles their property. The city’s website specifies the license remains the owner’s responsibility, not that of the management company.
