Michael Bilandic Building Chicago First District Appellate Court

The Michael J. Bilandic Building, Chicago, home of the Illinois First District Appellate Court

CHICAGO — An anesthesiologist can be considered an employee of a medical clinic and sue for allegedly unpaid wages, even though the specialist never entered into a formal employment contract with the clinic, the clinic was owned by a non-physician, and his pay was logged for tax purposes on form W-9 as an independent contractor, an Illinois state appeals panel has ruled.

On Nov. 13, a three-justice panel of the Illinois First District Appellate Court sided with Maher W. Fattouh, upholding the decision of the Illinois Department of Labor in Fattouh's dispute with the Hermosa Medical Diagnostic Center.

In the ruling, the First District justices said under Illinois law, Fattouh's work and alleged employment arrangement meant he should be considered an employee of the clinic on Chicago's northwest side, and not an independent contractor.

The case had landed at the appellate court after a Cook County judge had upheld a decision from an Illinois Labor Department's finding that Hermosa Clinic owed Fattouh $10,000 in allegedly unpaid wages, plus statutory damages of 2% per month the wages allegedly remained unpaid.

According to court documents, Fattouh, who was a resident of Wisconsin, reached an arrangement with the owners of the Hermosa clinic under which the anesthesiologist would provide services as a pain management specialist. Under the terms of the purported deal, Hermosa Medical would pay Fattouh $1,000 per day for one day of work per week for three months.

According to court documents, however, Fattouh hired a nurse practitioner "to schedule patients at the facility," who was then paid by the clinic "based on an understanding that Dr. Fattouh would reimburse the facility."

That nurse practitioner later left the clinic "because the facility could not continue paying her wages."

Fattouh was later terminated after working a total of 10 days at the clinic. The court documents do not describe a reason for the termination of his arrangement with Hermosa Medical.

However, following termination, Fattouh filed a complaint with the state Labor Department, asserting he was owed $10,000 under Illinois state wage law, plus the penalties.

In response, the clinic disputed the claim, asserting Fattouh was actually an independent contractor who never had a formal written employment contract with the clinic.

The clinic further asserted Fattouh's pay would have been expressed to the government on a W-9 form, which is provided by employers to independent contractors.

Fattouh, however, said he understood that he worked as an employee of the clinic. He asserted the clinic had "intentionally decided not to provide him with a written employment contract, so they could later argue that he was not an employee of the facility."

At the Labor Department, an administrative law judge sided with the doctor, determining he was an employee, as defined under Illinois wage law, as he received payment directly from the clinic as compensation for his services, which he provided "at the direction and under the control of" the clinic's owners.

The clinic's owners appealed to the Cook County Circuit Court, and again to the First District court.

But in both courts, Fattouh's arguments carried the case.

In the decision, the First District justices said Fattouh's arrangement with the clinic met all of the various tests used under Illinois wage law to determine if someone is an employee whose wages are protected under the state law or an independent contractor.

They noted, for instance, that the clinic "scheduled the doctor's patients;" clinic staff "handle the billing for the doctor's medical services;" and the clinic "retained the right to terminate the doctor's employment."

The appellate justices further rejected several other arguments from the clinic, including the clinic's attempts to claim they could not be considered Fattouh's direct employer under Illinois law, because the Hermosa clinic is not owned by a physician.

The parties disputed who the owner actually is. Fattouh claimed he was led to believe the owner was Richard Sharif, who is employed as a pharmacist. Sharif, however, claimed the clinic is owned by his sister, Ragda Sharifeh.

Regardless, neither sibling is a doctor.

The court, however, said that detail is of no concern in Fattouh's case, because the clinic and its owners failed to raise that concern during the Labor Department proceedings and Fattouh based his claim on the Illinois Wage Act, and not Illinois medical licensing laws, which govern who may directly employ doctors.

And the justices said the clinic was still licensed to provide health care.

"Here, there was no evidence that Hermosa-Medical was not licensed to provide medical services to the public, and at the time Dr. Fattouh began his employment with the medical facility, he was a duly licensed anesthesiologist, specializing in pain management," the justices wrote. "Accordingly, Dr. Fattouh’s employment with Hermosa-Medical did not violate the prohibition against the corporate practice of medicine."

The appellate court upheld the Labor Department's finding that Fattouh should be considered an employee of the clinic and owed the alleged unpaid wages.

The decision was authored by Justice Timothy Evans. Justices Celia Gamrath and Aurelia Pucinski concurred in the ruling.

The decision was issued as an unpublished order under Supreme Court Rule 23, which may limit its use as precedent.

More News