PARKERSBURG – A Wood County judge has rejected the City of Parkersburg’s attempt to overturn rulings in favor of current and former firefighters, ordering the city to immediately pay out their banked, unused holiday time at 1½ times their regular pay rates.
In a November 16 order, Circuit Judge John D. Beane also ruled the firefighters are entitled to reasonable attorney fees and court costs. He scheduled a damages hearing for January 13 with the plaintiffs’ expert report to serve as a guide for determining damages. The order does not set a total award.
The decision preserves Beane’s December 2022 ruling that holiday compensation must be calculated using the firefighters’ full 24-hour shifts and an October 2023 ruling requiring time-and-a-half payments when the city cashes out certain accumulated holiday hours.
“These wages being fought over were already earned by Parkersburg firefighters,” said Teresa Toriseva, an attorney representing the firefighters. “They’re past due. They had to go to court to recover them.
“Now the city owes interest, attorney’s fees and costs on top of all the wages that are owed. The law does not favor an employer who owes years of unpaid wages.”
The city had asked Beane to revisit his rulings in light of the state Supreme Court’s November 2023 decision in Nicewarner v. City of Morgantown, another firefighter holiday pay case. According to Beane’s order, Parkersburg argued the earlier summary judgment ruling had to conform to that decision.
In Nicewarner, the Supreme Court held firefighters were entitled to additional pay or time off, at their employer’s election, equal to the hours worked during a legal holiday or the hours they would have worked had the holiday not fallen on a regularly scheduled day off. The court rejected an automatic entitlement to 24 hours of holiday compensation in that case.
Beane found the Parkersburg case sufficiently different to leave his previous rulings intact.
“The Court’s December 12, 2022 Summary Judgment Order in favor of the Plaintiffs stands and remains in full effect,” he wrote.
Both departments’ firefighters work 24-hour shifts beginning at 8 a.m., but Beane pointed to differences in their scheduling. Morgantown uses three platoons, meaning one group works eight hours of a calendar holiday, another works 16 hours and a third is off for the entire holiday, according to the order.
Parkersburg uses two platoons. One works 16 hours of the calendar holiday and is off for eight, while the other works eight hours and is off for 16. Beane concluded those circumstances support 24 hours of holiday compensation because the statute provides benefits both for firefighters working during a holiday and those whose regularly scheduled time off falls on one.
He also cited evidence that Parkersburg calculates sick leave, vacation and bereavement leave using 24-hour shifts, while treating holiday benefits differently. Beane said his earlier ruling considered that evidence, distinguishing the record from the Morgantown litigation.
The order separately addresses Parkersburg’s practice of cashing out accumulated holiday leave twice a year.
During the period covered by the lawsuit, the city provided paid time off instead of premium holiday pay. But understaffing prevented firefighters from using the leave, causing their balances to accumulate, according to Beane’s findings. In July and December, the city paid down balances exceeding 100 hours at the firefighters’ regular hourly rates.
The firefighters challenged those straight-time payments, arguing the unused holiday hours had to be paid at time and a half. Beane agreed in October 2023 and reaffirmed that conclusion in the new order.
He said the forced cash-out claim was not presented or decided in Nicewarner and therefore supplied an independent reason to preserve the Parkersburg ruling.
Beane also concluded Rule 60(b), which governs relief from judgments, did not authorize the changes the city sought under the circumstances. On attorney fees, he found the firefighters had succeeded on both claims under the West Virginia Wage Payment and Collection Act and that the city had shown no special circumstances making an award unjust.
The ruling is the latest development in the litigation.
Related disputes have produced settlements elsewhere in the state.
In March 2022, Martinsburg agreed to a $1.75 million payment to a group of 37 firefighters as part of a settlement resolving holiday and overtime back pay claims and changing holiday compensation going forward.
Huntington City Council approved a separate settlement in August 2022 that included $415,000 in back pay, additional holiday leave provisions and payment of attorney fees and court costs. That agreement also accounted for the then-pending Supreme Court decision in the Morgantown case.
The Parkersburg plaintiffs are represented by Toriseva and Joshua D. Miller of Toriseva Law in Wheeling.
Wood Circuit Court case number 20-C-10
