West Virginia Auditor Mark Hunt
CHARLESTON – West Virginia Auditor Mark Hunt and four others have been indicted on federal charges involving allegations his office improperly transferred nine properties to benefit a longtime friend and paid a state employee for work at Hunt’s private law firm.
Moore Capito, U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia, announced the indictments November 16.
Hunt, 66, of Charleston, faces nine counts of theft of property and charges alleging he aided and abetted bank fraud. Prosecutors allege he personally issued tax deeds over career employees’ objections and knowingly allowed a state employee to collect government wages for work at his law office.
House Speaker Roger Hanshaw (R-Clay) called for Hunt’s immediate resignation following the announcement and warned the House of Delegates would act in January if he remains in office.
“These serious allegations cast a long shadow over the Office of the State Auditor and its role of maintaining the integrity of other state and local officials,” Hanshaw said Monday. “Every American is entitled to due process and the presumption of innocence in every criminal proceeding, but the public is entitled to leadership from the officers it elects.
“Mountaineers should always be free from the sort of taint these indictments create.”
Hanshaw did not specify in the statement what action the House would take.
“Auditor Hunt should immediately resign from his office,” he said. “If he resolves to do otherwise, the House of Delegates will take swift action in January to restore integrity to the Office of the West Virginia State Auditor.”
Also indicted on nine counts of theft of property each were David Keith Cole, 57, of Charleston, the auditor’s deputy chief of staff and office manager of Hunt’s private law firm; Frederic Scott Caudill, 59, of Charleston, the auditor’s general counsel; and Robert Lisle Johns, 66, of Charleston, a longtime Hunt friend and business associate who became special counsel for the auditor’s office in June 2025.
Cole and Caudill each face an additional count of making materially false statements to federal investigators.
Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, of Hurricane, an employee of the auditor’s office, was indicted on bank fraud charges, with Hunt and Cole accused of aiding and abetting the alleged scheme.
“Public officials are entrusted to serve the people, not use their offices for personal benefit,” Capito said. “When there is evidence that trust has been violated, our office will follow the facts and enforce the law, regardless of title or position.”
An indictment is an allegation, not a finding of guilt. All five defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The announcement did not include responses from the defendants or their attorneys.
According to prosecutors, a business associated with Johns sought to purchase nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties. Multiple career employees in the auditor’s Land Division determined the properties were legally ineligible for deed issuance because the purchaser had failed to make required payments and submit paperwork within statutory deadlines.
Over those employees’ objections, Hunt personally signed eight deeds March 28, 2025, and the ninth June 6, 2025, the indictments allege. Prosecutors say Caudill and Cole helped create and issue the deeds, resulting in the properties being taken from their lawful owners. Johns was hired as full-time special counsel that June.
The disputed deeds transferred properties to MAPA LLC, a company incorporated under Patricia Johns, Robert Johns’ wife. The transactions prompted Delegate Tristan Leavitt (R-Kanawha) to call for Hunt’s resignation.
Democratic lawmakers subsequently asked Hanshaw and Senate President Randy Smith (R-Preston) to seek a formal opinion from Attorney General J.B. McCuskey on Hunt’s authority to issue the deeds after statutory deadlines and approve transactions involving someone working for his office.
Before the indictments were announced, Hunt defended his actions as an effort to correct administrative mistakes and avoid litigation. He maintained that payments had arrived on time but paperwork had been mishandled,
“I would have done it for anyone who had the same problem,” Hunt said during an appearance last week on MetroNews’ Talkline statewide radio program. “The auditor certainly has discretion to correct mistakes.”
The indictments also accuse Caudill of making materially false statements during an October 26 FBI interview about the deeds, including whether he had asked office employees “who will be the whistleblower” regarding their handling. Cole allegedly made false statements during an October 6 FBI interview about the deeds and his approval of Hoffmann’s time sheets.
The bank fraud allegations cover a period beginning about May 5, 2025, and continuing through at least Sept. 29, 2026. Prosecutors allege Hoffmann left her state workplace on Friday afternoons to perform paralegal and administrative work at Mark A. Hunt & Associates while reporting those hours as government work.
Hunt knew about the arrangement, and Cole validated and approved the falsified timecards, according to the indictments. Hunt and Cole also frequently worked with Hoffmann at the law firm during state business hours on Fridays, prosecutors allege.
As a result, Hoffmann received state compensation, paid through the bank serving as West Virginia’s primary designated depository, for work she did not perform for the auditor’s office, prosecutors said.
The state Democratic Party called for Hunt and the indicted members of the auditor’s staff to resign.
“Mark Hunt told West Virginians this was nothing more than a ‘tempest in a teapot,’” Party Chairman Mike Pushkin said Monday. “Today’s indictments demonstrate that federal prosecutors believe this was something much, much more.
“These allegations strike at the very heart of an office charged with protecting taxpayers, safeguarding public property and exposing misconduct throughout state government.”
Pushkin, who also is a Kanawha County delegate, also commended Capito, the FBI and the state Commission on Special Investigations for moving swiftly to investigate the allegations and present evidence to a federal grand jury.
“U.S. Attorney Moore Capito deserves credit for following the evidence without regard to political party, title or position,” Pushkin said. “West Virginians expect the law to apply equally to everyone, especially those entrusted with overseeing public money and investigating wrongdoing. …
“An indictment is not a conviction, and every defendant is entitled to due process,” Pushkin concluded. “But the people of West Virginia are also entitled to an Auditor’s Office whose leadership is above reproach. Mark Hunt and the other indicted officials cannot credibly investigate waste, fraud and abuse while defending themselves against federal allegations that they used the office to commit those very offenses.”
Hunt, a Republican elected auditor in 2024, took office in January 2025. A Charleston attorney, he previously served 14 years in the House of Delegates and was elected to the state Senate’s 8th District in 2022.
His professional ties to the auditor’s office predate his election. According to his biography on the West Virginia Board of Treasury Investments website, Hunt worked as counsel to then-Auditor Glen Gainer after law school before establishing his private practice in late 1994.
Hunt earned a bachelor’s degree from the University of Charleston, a master’s degree in public administration from Marshall University and a law degree from the University of the District of Columbia, according to that biography.
The FBI and the West Virginia Commission on Special Investigations investigated the case. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Jonathan T. Storage and Joshua Hanks are prosecuting it.
