PaulHarris.jpg

Paul J. Harris

WHEELING – A former client and employee of an imprisoned Wheeling attorney is asking a judge to restore his control of a rental property company or order the former lawyer to pay $690,000 he says remains unpaid under an agreement to buy his ownership interest.

Emil R. Nardone II filed the lawsuit October 19 in Ohio Circuit Court alleging Paul J. Harris used proceeds from Nardone’s settlement in an earlier lawsuit to establish Hastings LLC, retained control of its finances and then made only one payment toward a $700,000 purchase agreement.

The ownership dispute also involves federal efforts to forfeit some of the company’s properties following Harris’ fraud and money laundering convictions. Nardone says the properties belong to the company he still owns, not to Harris.

According to the complaint, Harris began representing Nardone around 2013 in a Marshall County lawsuit against The Health Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley Inc. That case ended in a confidential settlement in May 2016.

Nardone alleges Harris advised him to invest a substantial portion of his settlement proceeds in a company that would buy rental properties. Under their arrangement, Nardone would own 99% of the company, while Harris would receive a 1% interest in exchange for managing the business while Nardone attended law school, the complaint says.

Harris organized Hastings in July 2016, according to the lawsuit. The company purchased property on National Road in Valley Grove for $45,400, apartments on Congress Avenue in Wheeling for $180,000 and townhomes on Hawk Court in Wheeling for $450,000. Nardone says his settlement proceeds provided all of the company’s initial funding.

After completing law school in spring 2019, Nardone began working as a law clerk in Harris’ office and took on rental management duties, including collecting rent, handling repairs and dealing with tenants, according to the complaint. But Harris refused or ignored repeated requests for access to bank statements, tax records and other financial information, Nardone alleges.

On August 1, 2020, Harris presented Nardone with an agreement to purchase his interest in Hastings for $700,000, payable in $10,000 monthly installments, the complaint says. Nardone alleges Harris drafted the documents, did not advise him to seek independent counsel and promised to make the payments from his own resources rather than company revenue.

The signed purchase agreement attached to the complaint states Nardone “hereby conveys all his right, title and interest in Hastings, LLC” to Harris for $700,000, payable under a separate promissory note. That note specifies 5% annual interest and monthly payments beginning August 1, 2020.

Nardone contends the documents, read together, made full payment a condition of transferring ownership. He alleges Harris paid only the first $10,000 installment and failed to cure the default after receiving written notice in June 2023.

“Our contract says you would pay me $10,000 a month,” Nardone wrote in an email included among the exhibits. “You have only made 1 payment in over 2 years?” Nardone wrote in an email included among the exhibits.

The complaint says federal prosecutors have sought to forfeit several Hawk Court properties and the National Road property as substitute assets belonging to Harris. Nardone says he has filed a petition in the federal forfeiture proceeding seeking a determination of his interest in those properties.

Harris was sentenced in March to 97 months in federal prison after a jury convicted him in November 2025 of 29 counts involving fraud and money laundering. Federal prosecutors said he used client money for personal expenses, including buying his home and paying off a loan on his law office, and sometimes used one client’s money to replace funds taken from others. U.S. District Judge John Preston Bailey also ordered $701,623.86 in restitution.

Nardone and Harris have been involved in litigation before involving a dispute connected to Nardone’s divorce from Healy Baumgardner — a former Fox News analyst and adviser to President Donald Trump and George W. Bush — regarding the Nardone Family Trust. In May 2022, an Ohio County judge ordered enforcement of a settlement, removed Harris as trustee and appointed a successor. Harris had submitted a resignation earlier that month.

In the new lawsuit, Nardone seeks a declaration that he remains the owner of a 99% interest in Hastings and that Harris has no authority to manage or act for the company. He also asks for control of its properties, accounts and records, an accounting of its finances and an injunction preventing Harris from selling, transferring or encumbering company assets while the case is pending.

Alternatively, if the court finds the 2020 agreement transferred ownership to Harris, Nardone seeks the alleged $690,000 unpaid balance, plus interest, late charges and attorney fees. He also asserts an alternative unjust enrichment claim seeking recovery of benefits Harris allegedly retained, including Nardone’s share of the company’s net income.

Hastings is named as a nominal defendant so the court can grant relief involving the company’s ownership.

Nardone, now a Florida resident, is being represented by Maximillian F. Nogay and Traci M. Cook of Maverick Litigation in Morgantown.

Circuit Judge David J. Sims entered an order October 26 appointing attorney DeMarr Moulton as a guardian ad litem for the limited purpose of accepting the lawsuit on Harris’ behalf and ensuring Harris personally receives the complaint and summons at Federal Correctional Institution Gilmer. The appointment does not require Moulton to advise Harris or otherwise defend the lawsuit.

Ohio Circuit Court case number: 26-C-172

More News