Downtown Philadelphia Street and Skyline
PHILADELPHIA – A disabled woman has filed a class action lawsuit against Philadelphia over its “Get Out the Bike Lane” bill, which was passed in 2024 and imposes penalties for anyone who stops, stands or parks a vehicle in a designated bicycle lane.
Susan Hess Herskovitz says this law violates the Americans with Disabilities Act in a Nov. 12 federal lawsuit, complaining that vehicles are fined for stopping to pick up or let out individuals with mobility problems.
Herskovitz is 85 years old and suffers from reflex sympathetic dystrophy and back pain that make her unable to walk long distances or carry heavy bags. Co-plaintiff Carl Roeder is in his 60s and suffered traumatic injuries in a 1988 automobile accident that leave him reliant on a cane to walk. He’s also currently undergoing chemotherapy, “which worsens his balance and neuropathy,” the lawsuit says.
Both live in the middle of their blocks, and they say they can’t walk to corners where cars are permitted to stop. Bike lanes in front of their homes are off-limits to vehicles transporting them, the suit says, without the threat of fines.
Absent an exemption for those with disabilities, the law violates the ADA, the suit says. Disability Rights Pennsylvania requested accommodations in a December letter to the City.
“The… rule strands relatives, friends and guests with mobility disabilities who come to those homes,” the suit says. “Each resident faces one rule and one missing exception, and one order can fix it.”
Bike lanes were installed on Pine and Spruce streets in 2009, and up until 2024 drivers could stop at their curbs to load passengers or let them out. That was changed when the City Council cited the July 2024 death of Dr. Barbara Friedes, a 30-year-old who was pediatric chief resident at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia.
She was killed when a drunk-driver struck her as she rode her bicycle near Rittenhouse Square. Michael Vahey pleaded guilty to several criminal charges and was sentenced to six to 20 years in prison. He also faces a civil lawsuit filed by Friedes’ family.
The tragedy spurred changes to Philadelphia’s bike-lane laws, approved by the City Council in October 2024. But councilmembers forgot about the strain this puts on the disabled, the class action lawsuit says.
“It makes no provision for a vehicle stopping briefly to let out or pick up a person with a mobility disability, for paratransit or for medical transport,” it says. “The prohibition applies in every designated bicycle lane in the City, not only in the Corridor.”
