First Court of Appeals in Houston
HOUSTON — The First Court of Appeals has wiped a default judgment of a quarter of a million dollars against an apartment complex.
The lawsuit was brought by Kimberly Aguilera, who sued Lavender Apartments alleging her belongings were taken.
According to Lavender’s appellate brief, beginning on April 1, 2023, Aguilera was a tenant at the Houston apartment complex and signed a one-year lease. She alleges that after she left her apartment in August 2023, at some point Lavender entered her apartment and removed her personal belongings.
The items allegedly removed included jewelry, clothing, furniture, and other items. Aguilera sued over the loss of this property and eventually received a default judgment.
After the suit was filed, the district clerk issued a citation directed to Lavender and a deputy constable filed a return of citation purportedly indicating service of the citation on June 7, 2024, court records show.
Lavender did not file an answer or otherwise appear in the case, and Aguilera moved for a default judgment, which the trial court granted, awarding her for $164,347.77 in economic damages, $81,516.38 in mental-anguish damages, and $4,135.85 in attorney fees.
Court records show Lavender did not participate in the hearing that resulted in the judgment or file a timely post-judgment motion, but did file a notice of restricted appeal within six months of the trial court’s judgment.
On appeal, Lavender Apartments asserts that service was defective on the face of the record and cannot support the default. The apartment complex also argues that it never received notice of the suit until long after the default judgment.
On Nov. 6, the First Court reversed the judgment and remanded the case, finding that the trial court erred.
“Lavender has established error apparent on the face of the record,” the opinion states. “Service of process was defective, and the trial court erred in granting a default judgment against Lavender.”
Appeals case No. 01-25-00270-CV
