TransFlag.jpg

KANSAS CITY — A former employee of The Summit Nursing Home in Kansas City has filed a federal lawsuit accusing the facility of sex discrimination, alleging management failed to address repeated harassment from residents because she is transgender and ultimately terminated her employment under a pretextual accusation of medication theft.

Cherish Nelson filed the complaint Nov. 2 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, bringing a claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. 

According to the complaint, Nelson is a transgender woman who was hired by The Summit Nursing Home in or around early January 2025. 

She alleges that throughout her employment, she faced hostility from residents because of her gender identity, including verbal harassment and refusals to accept meal and medication trays she delivered as part of her job responsibilities.

The complaint states that Nelson was open about being transgender while working at the facility. 

Her duties included delivering meal trays and medicine trays to residents. Although she frequently encountered residents who were hostile toward her because she is transgender, she continued to satisfactorily perform her job, according to the filing.

Nelson alleges that charge nurses at the facility became aware of the residents' hostility and warned her about certain individuals. 

One resident, identified in the complaint as Dana Purnell, allegedly refused to accept meal trays or medication trays from Nelson. 

The lawsuit further alleges that Purnell verbally berated her on multiple occasions, using profanity and pointedly referring to her as a "man."

Nelson claims she reported the residents' mistreatment to her supervisors multiple times. However, she alleges the facility's management team knew about the hostility she was experiencing and failed to take action to protect her or address the discriminatory treatment.

The complaint identifies March 6, 2025, as the date Nelson's employment was terminated. 

According to the filing, Vasantha Evans, a member of the facility's Human Resources Department, called Nelson into her office for a meeting and informed her that she was being fired over allegations that she had stolen residents' medications, particularly gabapentin.

Nelson denies stealing medication and alleges she immediately informed Evans that the accusation was untrue. 

She further contends that the medications were kept in secured carts monitored by security cameras, meaning footage would show each occasion on which she accessed the carts.

According to the lawsuit, Nelson asked Evans to review the security footage because she believed it would demonstrate that she had not stolen any medication. 

However, Evans allegedly refused to review the recordings, stating that Nelson might have intentionally blocked the cameras.

The complaint alleges that Evans had not reviewed the security footage at the time of Nelson's termination and instead relied on speculation that Nelson could have obstructed the cameras when making the decision to fire her.

Nelson contends that the medication theft allegation was a pretext for discrimination based on her being a transgender woman. 

The lawsuit alleges that The Summit Nursing Home, through its employees, managers and supervisors, permitted residents to discriminate against her because of her sex and her failure to conform to traditional sex stereotypes.

The complaint argues that the facility was aware of the discriminatory treatment Nelson experienced but made no attempt to remedy the situation. 

It further alleges that management's failure to intervene effectively authorized or condoned the conduct of employees and residents who mistreated her.

Nelson filed a formal Charge of Discrimination with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission on or about June 24, 2025. 

The EEOC acknowledged receipt of the charge on Sept. 5, 2025, according to the complaint. 

The filing states that the charge was submitted within 300 days of the last alleged discriminatory action, identified as the March 6, 2025, termination of her employment.

Nelson received a Notice of Right to Sue from the EEOC on or about Aug. 4. 

The lawsuit states that she filed the federal action within the required 90-day period and complied with the administrative requirements necessary before bringing the case.

Under Count I, Nelson alleges that The Summit Nursing Home violated Title VII through sex discrimination. 

She claims the facility's failure to address the treatment she experienced, combined with her eventual termination, constituted unlawful discrimination.

The lawsuit alleges that the facility's conduct caused Nelson to suffer lost wages and employment benefits, as well as humiliation, degradation, embarrassment, emotional distress, mental anguish, loss of self-esteem and deprivation of her civil rights. 

She also alleges the defendant's actions were wanton and willful and demonstrated disregard for the rights of others, which she argues justifies an award of punitive damages.

Nelson is seeking economic damages, compensatory damages, punitive damages, reasonable attorney fees and litigation costs, as well as pre- and post-judgment interest and any additional legal or equitable relief the court considers appropriate.

The lawsuit seeks economic, compensatory and punitive damages, along with attorney fees, court costs and other relief. Nelson has also requested a jury trial in Kansas City. She is represented by Mary Madeline Johnson of Missouri Kansas Queer Law.

U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri case number: 4:26-cv-01017

More News