Katherine_DeBriere_National_Health_Law_Program.jpg

Katherine DeBriere, senior attorney at the National Health Law Program

A federal appeals court has affirmed that Florida officials violated the due-process rights of Medicaid recipients who were cut from the health-care program based on confusing and inadequate termination notices issued in 2023 and 2024.

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals on Nov. 4 affirmed a previous district court decision that ordered the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration and the Department of Children and Family Services (DCF) to fully explain why the state was ending a recipient’s coverage.

The decision, written by former Florida Supreme Court Judge Barbara Lagoa, will prevent hundreds of thousands of Floridians from the illegitimate loss of their health care coverage, according to the Florida Health Justice Project, which represented plaintiffs in the case. The plaintiffs had challenged their termination notices as a violation of the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment.

“After a bench trial, the district court agreed and entered a declaratory judgment in favor of plaintiffs, along with a permanent injunction requiring Florida to provide that information before terminating a class member’s Medicaid benefits,” the appeals court said. “After careful review, and with the benefit of oral argument, we affirm.”

Neither the Agency for Health Care Administration nor the Florida Attorney General’s Office responded to requests for comment.

The plaintiffs received their termination notices during what was called Medicaid “unwinding” in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, when Medicaid eligibility rules were temporarily suspended. When eligibility reviews later resumed, Florida officials were required to explain to recipients why they were being terminated, including information on applicable income limits and family size calculations, the court said 

“For an income-based termination, the notice must include, ‘at a minimum,’ the enrollee’s ‘household size … and countable income’ and identify ‘the eligibility category in which the enrollee had been receiving benefits,’ including the reason for any change,” the appeals court said.

But the court found that such required explanations were not provided to the plaintiffs. One plaintiff, Chianne D., was told by a DCF agent that she would be covered by Medicaid through May 2024 when in fact the agency was in the process of terminating her medical coverage, the court’s opinion states.

“Based on the evidence before it, the district court did not err in concluding that Florida’s notices fail to meet due-process requirements because they are too vague and confusing to reasonably inform recipients what action the state intends to take, to whom that action applies or why the state is taking it,” the court said.

The Health Justice Project reported that wrongful Medicaid terminations affected newborns, new mothers and families with children with disabilities. 

“These families faced a maze of complex rules and regulations with no help from the state Medicaid agency, problems that the appellate judges described at oral argument as ‘systemic,’ ‘pretty bad,’ an ‘abject failure,’ even asking Florida ‘What is the whole point of hiding this information?’” the project said in a news release.

The National Health Law Program reported that Medicaid eligibility changes will become even more concerning as states begin implementing the federal One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), which will put in place Medicaid work requirements.

“People need enough information to understand why the state proposes to end their coverage and to challenge mistakes,” Katherine DeBriere, senior attorney at the National Health Law Program, said in a prepared statement. “States must build those protections into their systems now. Confusing notices and inaccessible explanations put people’s health care at risk.”

In its ruling the 11th Circuit’s three-judge panel concluded that Florida’s Medicaid call centers and online resources did not make up for deficiencies in the termination notices, since agents’ information was not always accurate and the system was at times overloaded.

“In April 2024, DCF blocked 744,000 calls before they could enter a queue for a live agent, representing 53.9% of the calls requesting an agent,” the opinion states.

More News