FORT MYERS, Fla. – A veterinary technician who suffered a shoulder injury on the job claims a Lee County pet hospital did not have a legitimate reason to terminate her employment.
Plaintiff Cindy Goldstein filed her suit October 28 in U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Fort Myers Division.
Goldstein, who worked at defendant BluePearl Vet LLC for nearly eight years, argues her termination stemmed from her employer’s “animus” toward her disability and her need for accommodation under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.
She alleges, in her 12-page filing, that BluePearl violated the ADA and the Florida Workers’ Compensation Retaliation Statute.
“It is clear that Defendant terminated Plaintiff because she was injured on the job, applied for workers compensation, suffered a disability/perceived disability, and required reasonable, non-burdensome accommodation for same,” the complaint states.
“Any other ‘reason’ theorized after the fact by Defendant or its attorneys for Defendant’s termination of Plaintiff’s employment is pure pretext.”
On July 16, Goldstein filed a charge of discrimination with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and Florida Commission on Human Relations, alleging disability discrimination and retaliation against BluePearl.
In August, the EEOC issued a notice of right to sue against the defendant, giving her the right to bring a civil action on her federal discrimination claims within 90 days of her receipt of the same.
Goldstein worked as a surgery veterinary technician from Dec. 11, 2018 until her termination March 5, 2026.
She notes in her complaint that she was an “excellent” employee and had “no significant history” of non-medical attendance, disciplinary, or performance issues.
On Feb. 19, 2026 Goldstein and co-worker Kacie Dunn were moving a heavy Labrador retriever from a gurney to an x-ray table when Dunn accidentally stepped on a pedal that moves the x-ray table. The resulting movement caused Goldstein to suffer a shoulder injury.
Goldstein immediately reported the incident to BluePearl Assistant Manager Craig Schuette, who advised her to file an injury report. She filed a claim for workers’ compensation soon after.
By late February, she still had not received any notification from BluePearl regarding workers’ compensation medical attention, so she followed up with Manager Amanda Motley to request the reasonable accommodation of light duty until she recovered.
On March 2, 2026, she was instructed to go to Concentra Urgent Care for medical attention. Two days later, she went to the urgent care and was diagnosed with a left shoulder strain. The physician recommended a five-pound limit for gripping, lifting, pushing, and pulling.
The very next day, on March 5, 2026, Motley and Technician Manager Rachel Galloway informed Goldstein that BluePearl had decided to terminate her employment, effective immediately.
Plaintiff was told her employment was terminated because she had “underdosed” a patient.
“The incident involved a patient who experienced low blood pressure while under anesthesia, for which Plaintiff administered less medication than was needed,” the filing states. “The patient suffered no harm from the underdosing and survived and recovered from the surgical procedure.
“Other employees had been retained despite committing more serious errors.”
The only difference, Goldstein argues, is that she was injured on the job and sought accommodations.
“Yet, shortly after Plaintiff applied for worker’s compensation and sought medical attention for a temporary disability requiring accommodations, such became a terminable offense,” her suit states.
“A causal connection exists between Plaintiff’s protected activity and Defendant’s retaliatory conduct.”
Goldstein seeks back pay, other monetary damages, equitable relief, front pay, declaratory relief, compensatory damages, punitive damages and attorney fees.
Richard Celler Legal PA in Plantation, Florida, is representing Goldstein in the case.
