delta-air-lines-plane-pittsburgh-international-airport.png

A Delta Air Lines jet approaches Pittsburgh International Airport in Moon Township, Pa.

ST. PAUL, Minn. - A Delta Air Lines flight attendant described as having “a lifelong struggle” with skin problems can’t obtain Workers’ Compensation benefits for skin and respiratory reactions she blamed on toxic uniforms.

A Workers’ Compensation appellate panel was wrong to reject an administrative judge’s finding in support of an expert’s opinion that the uniform wasn’t to blame, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled. By ruling the expert’s report unreliable, the appeals court “improperly substituted its own finding” for that of the administrative judge, the court said in a Nov. 12 decision.

The decision is consistent with a 2025 ruling by the Seventh Court of Appeals dismissing a class action by hundreds of Delta employees against Lands’ End over those same uniforms. The Seventh Circuit upheld a trial court order finding plaintiff experts to be unreliable.

Delta issued the uniforms to 64,000 employees in 2018 after testing them with 1,000 flight attendants, gate agents and other workers for several months with no complaints. Hundreds of employees later complained the uniforms were defective and contained toxic chemicals.

Jennifer Williams sought Workers’ Comp benefits in 2020 for skin and respiratory problems she said were caused by the supposedly toxic uniforms. She claimed she developed a rash after wearing the new uniform and later had respiratory problems caused by sitting next to another employee wearing the uniform. 

She submitted medical records including from a physician assistant who reported her skin became inflamed and her “face began to look puffy around the eyes” after she put on the uniform. Her doctor said he couldn’t say for certain the uniform caused her symptoms but he noted other Delta employees were making similar complaints.

Delta submitted opinions by Dr. Andrew Topliff, who said Williams’ symptoms weren’t caused by the uniform but could be explained by her lifelong history of allergies, rashes and allergic reactions. He disagreed with Williams’ doctor’s lab test results because the doctor hadn’t performed any baseline studies to compare against.

A Workers’ Comp judge rejected her request for benefits, but the appeals board reversed, finding Dr. Top;iff’s opinions were unreliable because he hadn’t fully considered the findings of Williams’ doctor. Delta appealed to the Minnesota Supreme Court, which ruled the appeals court hadn’t given proper deference to the administrative judge.

A reasonable person could agree that the judge’s findings were supported by the evidence, the court ruled. The appellate panel “should have deferred to those findings rather than substituting its own judgment,” it said. 

More News