surgeon-handing-surgical-tool-in-operating-room.jpg

A surgeon passes a clamp to a team member during an operation under focused lights.

NEW YORK - The New York City Housing Authority has joined the list of organizations suing a Brooklyn surgeon for allegedly performing unnecessary surgeries on patients to bolster their claims in civil lawsuits.

The housing agency sued Dr. Michael Gerling after he performed three spinal surgeries on a roofer named Jetnor Isufi, who fell off a truck and was treated for a sore wrist in the emergency room. After Isufi hired lawyers at Lipsig, Freund & Wisell, he was referred to Dr. Gerling, who performed a series of operations on his spine over two years. Based on his doctor’s records, Isufi claims he is incapacitated and seeking $7 million in damages from the city.

Dr. Gerling performed “surgeries with knowledge that the same were not objectively medically indicated, necessary, or appropriate,” the housing authority says in its lawsuit. 

Dr. Gerling and his clinic, NY Orthopedics, are at the center of multiple lawsuits accusing the doctor of working with plaintiff lawyers to inflate the value of slip-and-fall and workplace accident lawsuits. He has been accused of operating unnecessarily on a mentally ill patient and illegal immigrants who rarely receive the benefits of the lawsuits they are ostensibly the plaintiffs in. Most of the money from insurance settlements flows to their lawyers, doctors and outside financiers that loan against the claims.

The first wave of lawsuits were filed by insurance companies who claimed they were the victims of racketeering and fraud. New York judges have dismissed most of those cases, ruling the insurers weren’t the direct victims of the alleged fraud. 

Now government entities are joining the fight. Last month, New York City filed a racketeering lawsuit against plaintiff law firm Asher & Associates, citing 15 examples of what it calls “false narratives” in which clients sought money from the city for injuries they blamed on poorly maintained roadways but were contradicted by their own medical records.

The housing agency accuses Dr. Gerling and a former assistant, Matthew Miller, of performing unnecessary surgeries on Isufi without maintaining required records including MRI images or pathology reports. Dr. Gerling allegedly recommended cervical discectomy and fusion surgery on his first meeting with the worker even though his emergency room report showed only pain in his right wrist. In his list of damages, Isufi includes “internal derangement of the right shoulder,” disc herniations, spinal arthritis, problems with his lymphatic system and “contusions and abrasions.”

Dr. Gerling went on to perform spinal fusion and removed a supposedly herniated disk without ordering any MRI or other scans to confirm the surgeries were necessary, the housing authority says in its lawsuit filed Oct. 12. A final surgery was performed in May 2024, two years after Isufi fell off the truck and first presented his claims to the city for payment. Because he fell, the plaintiff can sue under New York’s “gravity law,” which allows plaintiffs to recover damages from property owners in addition to claiming benefits under Workers’ Compensation.

Isufi’s lawyers have moved to separate the city’s claims from his underlying lawsuit, saying the question of whether Dr. Gerling performed unnecessary surgeries is irrelevant to the plaintiff’s claim the city was negligent for causing him to fall off the truck.

More News