Hyatt

Hyatt hotel

SAN FRANCISCO — A San Francisco federal judge has evicted a lawsuit accusing Hyatt hotels of violating disability laws through its use of fragrant bath products.

Lawyers at the Oakland firm of Cole & Van Note filed a putative class action in June, on behalf of three named plaintiffs — with a fourth added on an amended complaint — alleging the hotelier “flooded its common and private areas” via scent dispersion machines “so as to atomize and deliver a steady stream of toxic compounds” despite knowing the potential of such mixtures to “trigger various acute reactions and lead to chronic pathological conditions” among patrons.

Cole & Van Note has targeted more than 20 companies in similar Americans with Disabilities Act lawsuits, including hotels, resorts, cruise lines, rental car firms and Whole Foods, and maintains a website indicating plans to target nationwide brands in other sectors, such as retail, medical and wellness. The complaints commonly allege almost 27% of American adults suffer from asthma or similar conditions while more than 27% have a diagnosed chemical sensitivity and at least 85% of “susceptible segments of the population,” such as those with autism, can experience “disabling effects” from exposure to air treated to have a particular aroma.

The Hyatt complaint claimed “the effects of these synthetic fragranced consumer products adversely affect all human beings but, for those with recognized disabilities such as fragrance/chemical and/or multiple chemical sensitivities, autism, and so on, the fear, apprehension and emotional distress alone of coming into contact with fragrance can be intense, as are the physiological manifestations predictably attendant to the exposure.

“Even for those persons lucky enough to not possess/share chemical/fragrance susceptibility at such heightened levels, their exposure to fragrance remains, at best, an annoyance, an unwanted touching (i.e., a battery) by atomized fragrance particulates and/or a disruption to their shopping, dining, lodging and/or other services offered at the fragrance location.”

The complaint alleged people who have experienced synthetic fragrance at a Hyatt properly are functionally “prohibited every day from safe and healthy access” to the otherwise public accommodations, while those visiting for the first time can be blindsided: “by the time these unsuspecting visitors are aware of the pervasive scents/toxins, it is simply too late: the toxins have already been ingested, have landed upon the skin, have entered the lungs and, thus, entered these victims’ bloodstreams (by design) and targeted various organs/systems.”

In addition to class certification, legal fees, a jury trial and a finding of ADA violations, the plaintiffs are pursuing a court order stopping Hyatt from using synthetic fragrance products in its American facilities — or at least limiting it to areas where customers can request and consent — as well as an order making Hyatt “provide a form of corrective advertising” regarding alleged misrepresentations as well as another order creating a constructive trust for all money Hyatt earned “as a result of the unfair, misleading, fraudulent and unlawful conduct alleged” in the complaint.

In an opinion filed Nov. 10, U.S. District Judge William Orrick dismissed the complaint for lack of standing.

“The central problem,” Orrick wrote, “is that it does not appear plausible that Hyatt is a proper defendant.”

Christopher Kovacs and Shannon Teinert alleged they visited Florida Hyatt Place locations at the Pensacola airport and in Sarasota/Lakewood Ranch, but they didn’t respond to a sworn declaration from a Hyatt executive who indicated neither Hyatt nor its subsidiaries ever owned or operated those facilities.

The other plaintiffs, Michelle Pollok and Tina Westman, “do not provide any allegations showing an intent to return to a Hyatt property or deterrence from visiting in the first place,” Orrick wrote. “They also do not provide any facts connecting their purported injury to a specific Hyatt property. Instead, the two plead that their health conditions prevent them from accessing Hyatt’s facilities, ‘so long as these facilities continue to expose patrons to fragranced substances.’ That alone is insufficient to establish standing.”

Orrick granted the plaintiffs 20 days to further amend their complaint and said he didn’t consider any of Hyatt’s other arguments in favor of dismissal.

More News