philadelphiaschools.jpg

Philadelphia Board of Education Building

PHILADELPHIA - The Philadelphia School District must reinstate with back pay a teacher who was fired for refusing weekly Covid-19 testing because no district board members were present at his termination hearing, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled.

Upholding a decision by the Commonwealth Court, the Supreme Court said Section 1127 of the state School Code requires a termination hearing “before the board of school directors” and that means at least some of them must be physically present.

“Because the Code means what it says, we affirm the Commonwealth Court,” the high court said in a Nov. 17 decision. 

Neil Follman was fired after he refused a Philadelphia School District requirement for weekly Covid-19 testing in the spring of 2021. His principal recommended he be fired, and a hearing officer with the district’s labor relations office agreed. 

The Board of Education sent Follman a termination notice along with an invitation to attend a board meeting on Sept. 13, 2021. The meeting was postponed, then switched to a virtual meeting over Follman’s objections. None of the board members were present at that meeting, only a hearing officer, after which the board voted to fire Follman.

Follman appealed to the state Education Secretary, arguing at least some of the nine board members were required to attend his hearing. The Secretary rejected his appeal, saying “the Board reviewed the hearing officer’s findings of facts, conclusions of law and recommendation, and then made an independent ruling based on the entire record.”

Follman took the matter to Commonwealth Court, where a three-judge panel unanimously reversed the Secretary’s decision, citing Section 1127, which governs how contract employees can be terminated. In addition to requiring a hearing, the law requires a board member to administer an oath to any witnesses, the court said, making it impossible to hear witnesses without a board member present.

The trial court didn’t decide how many directors must attend the hearing, but because zero board members attended the hearing in this case, the court said it violated the law. The court ordered Follman to be reinstated with back pay.

The district appealed, arguing the “broader context” of the school code should mean the board can appoint a hearing officer to take evidence on its behalf. Another part of the code authorizes school boards to do whatever is necessary to carry out the law and appoint people and “define their duties.”

The Pennsylvania School Boards Association submitted a friend-of-the-court brief, saying the lower court’s decision called into question longstanding administrative agency practices throughout the state. Many other statutes, if read literally, would require agency heads to conduct hearings now left to administrative law judges, the association said.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed the trial court, however, ruling there was no need to read into the school code “something other than its literal meaning.” By requiring school board members to sign hearing notices and administer the oath to witnesses, the legislature clearly intended for them to be present at termination hearings, the court said in an opinion by Chief Justice Debra Todd.

“The rule that statutory language must be read `in context’ does not empower judges to squint at a law, claim to discern from the overall gestalt of the statute some broad plan or goal that we think the legislature must have had in mind, and then disregard unambiguous language that conflicts with that supposed goal,” the court said.

Justice Daniel McCaffery concurred but said the court should have decided that the full board must be present  at termination hearings. The majority opinion “stops short of providing clear guidance to the school districts that conduct these types of hearings,” he wrote, and leaving the question open guarantees future litigation over how many board members must be present.

Justice P. Kevin Brobson dissented, saying the court interpreted the law too literally.

“The term ‘hear’ can mean ‘to give a legal hearing to’ and `to take testimony from,’” he wrote, and “before” can mean “under the official or formal consideration of.”

“In my view, none of the above-defined terms require that members of a school board personally attend a termination hearing,” he wrote. “This state of affairs will almost certainly result in future litigation concerning challenges to the number of school board members that must be present at termination hearings, as well as credibility disputes between school board members who hear live testimony and those who review the cold record—issues that my interpretation of the School Code avoids.”

More News