The California state flag flies alongside the U.S. flag.
FRESNO — The state of California doesn't have to force health insurers to completely cover all pregnancy care before the state can ban insurers from charging copays or deductibles for abortions, a state appeals panel has ruled.
On Nov. 17, a three-justice panel of the California Fifth District Court of Appeal rejected a challenge by pro-life activists to California's so-called Abortion Accessibility Act.
The decision comes as the latest step in a years-long court fight over whether the state of California violated constitutional protections for some women when the state's Democratic legislative supermajority enacted the 2022 law essentially making abortion services free of out-of-pocket cost for women undergoing the procedure.
The lawsuit was lodged in Kern County Superior Court by the Bakersfield Crisis Pregnancy Center, an organization that seeks to reduce the number of abortions in that community. They were joined by individual plaintiffs, identified as Erin Rogers and two obstetricians, Patrick Baggot and Steven Braatz.
In the lawsuit, the plaintiffs asserted the pro-abortion law violated equal protection rights of women who seek to keep their babies, rather than abort.
They argued California could not force insurers to pay for all abortion costs, while simultaneously allowing insurers to impose cost-sharing terms on women who carry their pregnancies to term and desire to birth healthy babies.
The effect of the law, they said, was to persuade some women who otherwise would have decided to keep their babies to instead opt to abort. They said this improperly inserted the state into women's private reproductive decisions, in violation of their state constitutional rights.
In court, however, judges at both the county Superior Court and now, at the appellate level, all said the law passes constitutional muster.
Under the so-called rational basis standard of constitutional review, the judges said state lawmakers need only show that they relied on a "rational basis" to justify the state's desire to promote abortion.
And in this case, the judges said state lawmakers need only show that they desired to ensure that health insurance copays and deductibles wouldn't serve to prevent women from exercising their rights guaranteed under the California state constitution to terminate their pregnancies through abortion.
The judges further noted that after the state passed the law, the number of women who underwent abortions using private insurance increased slightly, demonstrating lawmakers were not out of bounds to conclude the law was needed to "remove barriers" to abortion services.
"Here, the removal of barriers is a plausible reason for eliminating cost sharing for woman who choose to have an abortion," the appellate justices wrote.
The justices also explicitly rejected the contention that the state's decision to make abortions essentially free for women, while potentially leaving women saddled with costs for birthing live babies, should mean the state violated women's privacy rights.
They said women remain free to choose to carry their babies to term or abort, even if costs may differ.
"Difference in funding for the different choices women make do not automatically result in the requisite adverse influence upon the right to choose between the two alternatives," the appeals court wrote.
The decision was authored by Fifth District Justice Donald R. Franson Jr.. Justices Herbert I. Levy and Thomas DeSantos concurred in the ruling.
