JudgeGavel.jpg

HOUSTON -- A dissenting justice in an appeal of a $3.25 million verdict recently opined that attempting to solo-transfer a 400-pound patient is so “obviously dangerous” that the medical provider owed no duty to warn of danger.

On Nov. 5, the 14th Court of Appeals issued an opinion in litigation brought by Nicole Tarpley against Red BLuff, LLC, keeping most of the multi-million dollar judgment intact.

In her suit, Tarpley alleged she was injured when a morbidly obese patient fell onto her leg as she attempted to assist him from a bed to a wheelchair.

A jury found in Tarpley’s favor, awarding her $500,000 for future medical expenses, $750,000 for past physical impairment and $2,000,000 for future physical impairment.

She was also awarded $360,000 for past medical care, $750,000 for past physical pain, $2 million for future physical pain, and $750,000 in mental anguish damages, but those damages were not addressed in the opinion. 

The 14th Court concluded that Red Bluff owed a duty to exercise ordinary care in training Tarpley how to safely transfer the obese patient from his bed to a wheelchair. 

The majority of justices found the evidence legally sufficient to support the medical expenses award, but rejected this issue in part because the amount awarded exceeds the amount of future medical expenses the jury reasonably could have accepted based on expert medical evidence. 

They concluded the evidence is sufficient to support an award of $235,551.49 in future medical care expenses, suggesting a remittitur of $264,448.51. 

The majority further held the evidence is legally and factually sufficient to support the damage awards for past and future physical impairment.   

Justice Tonya McLaughlin dissented, however, opining that Tarpley did not ask for help and there is no evidence suggesting that Red Bluff would not have provided assistance had she asked for it.

“I dissent because attempting to solo-transfer a 400-pound patient is so obviously dangerous that caselaw dictates Red Bluff owed Tarpley no duty to warn her of such a danger so clearly within common knowledge,” McLaughlin opined.

More News