A Union Pacific locomotive
HOUSTON — The 14th Court of Appeals of Texas has gutted a jury verdict of more than $1.7 million against United Pacific Railroad, finding there was insufficient evidence to support the total amount of damages awarded.
This lawsuit, brought by Travis Gozan, arises out of a workplace incident at a railyard, according to the 14th Court’s Nov. 10 opinion.
Gozan, a UPR employee, was riding as a passenger in a Kawasaki Mule, a lightweight utility vehicle, when the driver, who was also a UPR employee, failed to maintain control of the Mule, hopped a small curb, and collided with a building.
The Mule had been traveling at a low speed and Gozan was wearing his seatbelt. He walked away from the accident, but he later felt “discombobulated,” and asked his father to transport him to the hospital, court records state.
Gozan arrived at the emergency room, complaining of lower back pain that radiated down the leg. He also complained of a headache, blurred vision, and tightness in his shoulder. He denied any blows to the head, neck pain, or loss of consciousness.
“His physical examination was unremarkable,” the opinion states. “Gozan visited his primary doctor three days later. That doctor cleared Gozan to return to work in two weeks, but Gozan did not return to work at the end of that two-week period. Instead, he retained legal counsel and filed a written report of injury with Union Pacific, complaining of ‘injury to head, back, butt, vision, & legs shoulders.’”
At trial, the jury found UPR negligent, awarding Gozan $1,732,000 in damages, which included $60,000 for past pain, $390,000 for future pain, $40,000 for past mental anguish, $52,000 for future mental anguish, $40,000 for his past impairment, $150,000 for future impairment and $1 million for future medical expenses.
Justices concluded that there was sufficient evidence of causation as to both of Gozan’s claims for lifelong medical conditions, but insufficient evidence to support the total amount of damages.
“The trial court’s judgment is reversed and the case is remanded for a new trial on Gozan’s claim for negligence, including all categories of damages except past and future mental anguish, for which Gozan shall take nothing,” the opinion states.
Appeals case No. 14-25-00794-CV
