School.jpg

CHARLESTON – State officials are asking the West Virginia Supreme Court to dismiss a Lincoln County student’s challenge to the state’s school funding formula, while the student’s attorneys say promises of legislative reform should not postpone judicial review.

In a November 13 motion, attorneys for a group of state respondents argue the Legislature’s presiding officers are immune from the lawsuit and the student has not established legal standing. In a separate November 9 filing opposing a request to put the case on hold, the student’s attorneys warn further delay could leave children in inadequately funded classrooms and allow more schools to close.

The case was filed in September by a Lincoln County sixth grader identified as M.D. through her mother Lakin Patten. The petition challenges the constitutionality of West Virginia’s school financing system and alleges officials have failed to meet their obligation to maintain a “thorough and efficient” system of free schools under Article XII, Section 1 of the state Constitution.

In their filing, the state officials say the petition improperly seeks to compel legislative action. In the other one, the student’s attorneys say constitutional guidance from the justices would help lawmakers craft legally adequate reforms.

“Petitioner takes issue with the Legislature’s choice not to pass a school funding bill to her preferred specifications,” the dismissal motion states. “But when the Legislature’s choices disappoint, the Constitution’s answer is an election, not a writ.”

Attorney General J.B. McCuskey’s office filed the motion on behalf of the House Speaker Roger Hanshaw (R-Clay), state Senate President Randy Smith (R-Preston), state Auditor Mark Hunt, state Treasurer Larry Pack, state Tax Commissioner Matthrew Irby, the state Department of Education, the state Board of Education, the School Building Authority, State Superintendent Michele Blatt, Lincoln County school officials and other state and county officials.

The motion asks the court to dismiss the legislative leaders with prejudice on immunity grounds and dismiss the petition without prejudice for lack of standing, or at least dismiss the claims against the state respondents joining the motion.

The officials argue the state Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause and statutes enacted in 2005 and 2022 protect the legislative leaders from claims arising from the creation, passage or amendment of the school funding formula. Those protections also cover decisions not to enact legislation or follow recommendations from education officials, they contend.

The motion cites West Virginia Code § 55-17-3a, which the officials say requires dismissal of the Legislature or its presiding officers from lawsuits challenging a statute’s constitutionality and bars courts from ordering the Legislature to act through a writ of mandamus.

The officials argue those limits do not prevent judicial review of state laws. Instead, they say constitutional challenges should proceed against officials responsible for carrying out the laws, rather than legislators who enacted them.

They also contend the student has not identified a specific injury to her education or shown how an order against the officials she sued would remedy it.

“The Petition is brought ‘to protect (M.D.’s) interests,’ yet it never says which school she attends, what she has been denied, or how the formula has damaged her education,” the motion states. “It speaks of the state’s schools and Lincoln County’s schools, not hers.”

The officials separately challenge the petition’s invocation of taxpayer standing, arguing Patten is acting on her daughter’s behalf rather than as the petitioner herself. They say the record lacks evidence establishing the taxpayer, citizenship or voter status needed to support that theory of standing.

The student’s November 9 response addresses a different request: the state officials’ motion to hold the case in abeyance while lawmakers consider school funding changes. That response was filed four days before the dismissal motion.

ACLU of West Virginia Foundation attorneys Aubrey Sparks and Robb Livingood argue lawmakers have had years to address the alleged deficiencies and should not receive another delay based on the possibility of action during the 2027 legislative session.

“While it is the purview of the Legislature to determine policy, it is the role of this Court to interpret the Constitution and ensure its requirements are heeded,” their response states.

The attorneys cite funding recommendations the state Board of Education approved in 2018, subsequent cooperation between education officials and lawmakers, and public statements identifying the school aid formula as a legislative priority. They argue those earlier efforts undermine assurances that upcoming discussions will produce a constitutional system.

“Time after time, the state officer respondents and the bodies that they represent have acknowledged the need for action, have been afforded an opportunity to remedy constitutional deficiencies, and yet have failed to do so,” the response states.

The attorneys also distinguish changes in education policy from compliance with constitutional requirements. Even substantial revisions to the formula, they argue, might leave unresolved questions about funding adequacy, school quality and equity among school systems.

According to the response, the state officials have argued a pause would conserve resources by avoiding litigation over a funding system lawmakers might change. The student’s attorneys counter that review before the legislative session could help lawmakers avoid adopting another system vulnerable to the same constitutional objections.

They also dispute the suggestion that possible legislation would necessarily make the case moot, arguing the court could still provide relief if reforms fail to address the alleged violations.

School closures figure prominently in the student’s opposition to delay. The response says at least 18 West Virginia schools faced closure or consolidation when it was filed and cites statements from county superintendents connecting proposed closures to financial pressures.

“Some bells cannot be unrung; a closed school rarely reopens,” the attorneys write.

If the court grants the requested pause, the attorneys say they intend to seek a preliminary injunction limiting the state Department of Education’s and state Board of Education’s ability to approve school closure applications during the abeyance. They argue preserving schools while funding changes are considered would prevent irreversible harm to students and communities.

The attorneys urge the justices to provide guidance before or early in the 2027 legislative session, warning that another unsuccessful session could leave students waiting through another school year for relief.

“Children cannot be adequately compensated for lost educational opportunity, given the substantial cascading effects of the deficiency,” the response states. “Try as it might, a court order cannot improve a student’s reading comprehension or reverse time to provide an impressionable student with a qualified math instructor.”

The student is being represented by Sparks and Livingood. Solicitor General Michael R. Williams, Principal Deputy Solicitor General Holly J. Wilson and Assistant Solicitor General Madison T. Cash represent the state officials.

West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals case number 26-597

More News