Harmon Pritzker Welch

Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, flanked by Illinois Senate President Don Harmon, left, and House Speaker Emanuel "Chris" Welch, right

CHICAGO — Illinois will need to defend a state law that supporters say is designed to promote "diversity" on nonprofit organizational boards, but which critics say is designed to force nonprofits to discriminate against heterosexual white males, as a federal appeals panel has revived a legal challenge lodged by the Justice Department and others.

On Nov. 18, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower court's ruling that had pulled the plug on the lawsuit.

In the ruling, the appellate judges said it should have been apparent that both the federal government and the group known as the American Alliance for Equal Rights (AAER) have "standing" to sue the state of Illinois to block enforcement of the law at the heart of the case.

The legal dispute dates back to January 2025, when the AAER first filed suit to challenge the state law, known as Senate Bill 2930.

SB2930 would force nonprofit organizations in the state to publicly disclose the race, gender and other "demographic classifications" of their staff and board members.

Supporters of the measure, including Gov. JB Pritzker, have said the law is needed to support the state government's priorities and "encourage nonprofits to reflect the diversity of the communities they support."

In a release announcing the signing of the bill into law, for instance, Pritzker specifically indicated the law was part of his broader effort to "prioritize LGBTQ+ rights" in Illinois and to "expand on my administration's work to better serve the LGBTQ+ community of Illinois."

Other supporters of the measure have asserted the law is intended to spur "diversity" of race, gender and sexuality, among other protected characteristics, on the boards leading Illinois nonprofits, asserting Illinois' nonprofit leadership should match the demographics of the state.

The law took effect on Jan. 1, 2025.

Under the law, nonprofit corporations which "reports grants of $1 million or more to other charitable organizations" would be required to post on its website "the aggregated demographic information of the corporation's directors and officers, including race, ethnicity, gender, disability status, veteran status, sexual orientation and gender identity."

The information would be required to remain available for public review for at least three years.

A precise list of required "demographic classifications" would be determined by the Illinois Department of Human Rights, according to the text of the law.

In the legal action, the American Association for Equal Rights said the law amounts to an order from the state to discriminate or risk "public shaming" at the hands of state officials or others.

The AAER said the Constitution doesn't allow the state to order anyone to discriminate.

"And Illinois cannot end-run the Constitution's colorblind commands by 'encouraging' private actors to discriminate," the AAER said in its complaint.

The lawsuit asserts the compelled public disclosure ordered by SB2930 violates two constitutional freedoms: the First Amendment right "to speak freely and the right to refrain from speaking at all" and the constitutional right to "to be free from state-ordered racial discrimination."

Thomas Kirsch

U.S. Seventh Circuit Judge Thomas Kirsch

According to the lawsuit, the law unconstitutionally forces nonprofits to ask their staff disclose "if they are gay or straight, black or white, transgender or not," using the state's preferred terminology and classifications, and then forces the organization to "publish those answers on their own website for years."

The Justice Department under President Donald Trump joined the federal government to the action in March 2025. In moving to intervene, the Justice Department said they also believed the state law amounts to an unconstitutional edict compelling nonprofits to discriminate on the basis of race, gender, sexuality and other protected characteristics, but in favor of those preferred by Illinois Democrats.

"... The United States is not required to sit idly while its citizens are denied equal protection by a state," the Justice Department said in a filing in support of intervention.

In court, however, U.S. District Judge Sharon Johnson Coleman sided with the state, ruling that both the Justice Department and the AAER lacked "standing" under the law to sue to challenge the law.

Coleman ruled the parties could not demonstrate how SB2930 actually harms anyone covered by the law.

She particularly noted that the law allows people who might be required to report their race, gender or other demographic information to choose not to. Coleman said that choice means the law doesn't carry the force alleged by the plaintiffs.

The AAER and Justice Department appealed, saying Coleman's reasoning didn't match the law or legal precedent.

At the Seventh Circuit, the judicial panel agreed and revived the lawsuit.

The decision was authored by Seventh Circuit Judge Thomas Kirsch. Judges David Hamilton and Nancy Maldonado concurred. Kirsch was appointed by Trump during his first term in office. Hamilton was appointed by former President Barack Obama, and Maldonado, by former President Joe Biden.

In the ruling, Kirsch said legal precedent is clear that the federal government rarely lacks the ability to sue in court to protect perceived violations of Americans' constitutional rights by states or other parties.

"Put simply, the Supreme Court has consistently found that the United States has standing to enforce the rights of its citizens under the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution, especially when it has clear statutory authority to do so," Kirsch wrote. "And there is no doubt that the United States has standing to intervene here.

"To find otherwise would call into question the ability of the United States to defend its laws and the mandates of the Constitution."

And the AAER also has standing, the appeals judges said, because it is speaking for at least two member organizations who assert the law will illegally compel them to spend time and resources gathering potentially discriminatory demographic information from its members and leadership.

While Coleman said the law's opt-out provision blunts the impact of the requirements, Kirsch and his colleagues said they believed the law would still impose an unconstitutional burden by leaving nonprofit board members and others facing a difficult choice over whether to comply with the law or seek to defy the state's mandate.

"This conclusion does not require mere speculation or conjecture but rather is rooted in basic reality: When the law tells corporate officers and directors to do something, they typically comply," Kirsch wrote. "Especially given that SB 2930 asks about several demographic categories, many of them uncontroversial, it seems highly unlikely that not a single officer or director would respond with, say, their gender or veteran status.

"Then, if even one officer or director responds, the organization would be required to post that information, conferring standing," Kirsch wrote.

The judges remanded the case back to Coleman's court for further proceedings on the merits of the AAER and Justice Department legal challenges to SB2930.

More News