The Michael J. Bilandic Building, Chicago, home of the Illinois First District Appellate Court
CHICAGO — A state appeals panel has upheld a $7.5 million wrongful death lawsuit verdict given to a woman whose daughter died during childbirth.
Jeryis and Carlos Flores went to Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center in September 2018 for the delivery of their daughter, Cianie. Their 2020 lawsuit alleges Dr. Silvia Bichalho, an obstetrician, and nurse Josephine Jimenez didn’t take appropriate steps to monitor the baby and were late to offer necessary medical interventions, contributing to her death.
Cook County Circuit Court Judge Nichole Patton presided over a three-week jury trial in January 2025 that resulted in a verdict in the Flores’ favor and against the hospital and medical professionals. The defendants first sought a new trial, then challenged the verdict before the Illinois First District Appellate Court. The defendants specifically argued Patton improperly responded to a jury question and allowed the panel to impose liability without unanimously agreeing on the plaintiffs’ negligence theory, as well as that Patton abused discretion by refusing special interrogatories proposed by the defendants.
Justice Thaddeus Wilson wrote the panel’s opinion, filed Nov. 13; Justices Sharon Oden Johnson and Carl Walker concurred.
Wilson said the trial focused significantly on electronic fetal monitoring, which the panel explained involves three classifications: The first is normal, the third is “abnormal and may indicate significant fetal compromise requiring prompt intervention,” but the second, framed as “warrants continued evaluation,” was fodder for a dispute over what those tracings meant about Cianie’s specific condition and whether the delivery team should’ve intervened sooner.
At trial, Biachlo testified she became concerned about a changing heart pattern at roughly 12:40 p.m. By 12:48 p.m. an external monitor experienced increasing difficulty in logging the baby’s heart rate — Jimenez testified she couldn’t see a rate from 12:48 to 12:50 — and when Biachlo saw the tracing move to the third category she ordered emergency surgery at 12:51 p.m.
“Cianie was delivered at approximately 1:04 p.m. and did not survive,” Wilson wrote.
The panel first wrote it agreed with the defendants’ framing of what medical negligence patients must prove. But they ultimately said it is incorrect to insist all jurors must agree on which departure from the applicable standard of care may have caused the injury, in instances where plaintiffs proffer multiple allegations. Nor, they said, did the defendants’ case law “establish that each alleged act or omission is itself a separate finding requiring unanimous agreement.”
The parties also disputed the relevance of criminal cases that address jury unanimity. The panel noted such decisions aren’t controlling, but did find limited value in a distinction between “alternative means” and “multiple acts,” noting a 1999 U.S. Supreme Court opinion, Richardson v. United States, which explained that although criminal jurors have to unanimously agree on each alleged crime, they “need not always decide unanimously which of several possible sets of underlying brute facts make up a particular element” of the offense.
Under Illinois law, the panel continued, a jury can reach a unanimous finding of first-degree murder without agreeing on how the murder was committed.
However, Wilson said: “Multiple-acts cases present a different concern. They typically arise when a single count is supported by evidence of several factually distinct criminal acts, each of which could independently constitute the charged offense. The concern is not that jurors may disagree over how a single offense was committed, but that different jurors may convict based on different criminal acts without agreeing that the defendant committed any one of them.”
The Flores family raised three separate concerns about the doctor and nurse. Their obstetrical expert, Dr. Fred Duboe, said Bichalo shouldn’t have told Jeryis to “labor down” after 8:30 a.m., when she was fully dilated but the baby remained high in the birth canal. Duboe also said she should’ve placed a fetal scalp electrode by 11:15 a.m. and ordered the surgery between 12:15 and 12:20 p.m.
A nursing expert, Lindsay McDevitt, testified Jimenez should’ve questioned the labor down instruction, advocated for the electrode earlier and used the nursing chain of command if the doctor failed to respond to her concerns.
During deliberations, the jury asked if members had “to be unanimous on one count or can we be unanimous on any combination.” Judge Patton said it needed to decide if the doctor or nurse were negligent, but did not have to be unanimous on which specific act was negligent. The panel ultimately agreed her response didn’t “permit liability based merely on a general belief that a defendant had been negligent in some unspecified sense,” Wilson wrote.
“Each juror still had to find that the defendant departed from the applicable standard of care in at least one alleged respect and that the negligence found proximately caused plaintiffs’ injury. The jurors could disagree about which alleged departure supplied that basis, but each juror had to find both negligence and causation. The trial court therefore did not misstate Illinois law.”
After Patton answered the jury, the defense offered six special interrogatories for the jury, which Patton rejected as contradictory to her position on determining negligence. The first, Wilson wrote, was improper because it didn’t “ask the jury to decide a specific ultimate fact underlying liability. Instead, it asked whether the jurors agreed on the same alleged act or omission.”
The other five, which were specific to the Flores family’s allegations, also fell short because “none independently tested the general verdict,” Wilson continued. “A negative answer concerning any one of Dr. Bicalho’s alleged departures would leave the other two available to support the verdict against her. Likewise, a negative answer concerning either of the two departures addressed as to nurse Jimenez would leave other alleged departures unresolved. In each instance, therefore, a reasonable hypothesis remained under which the special finding and general verdict could be reconciled.”
The panel said it didn’t need to consider whether some questions improperly combined questions about departure from standard of care and proximate cause or whether the interrogatories were untimely — tendered after deliberations began — because they all failed at their first threshold.
“The jury was not required to agree on the same alleged departure, so the first interrogatory sought a finding that was not necessary to the verdict,” Wilson wrote. “The remaining interrogatories each left alternative allegations available to support liability and therefore could not independently test the general verdict. The trial court therefore did not abuse its discretion in refusing defendants’ proposed special interrogatories, and that ruling provides no basis for disturbing the judgment.”
The panel affirmed Judge Patton’s findings.
The Flores family is represented by the firm of Raymond & Raymond, of Schaumburg, and on appeal by attorney Michael T. Reagan, of Ottawa.
The medical defendants are represented by attorneys from the firm of Taft Stettinius & Hollister, of Chicago.
