NEW ORLEANS – The St. Bernard Parish School Board has filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Army Corp of Engineers, citing concerns over an environmental assessment that claims a $1.8 billion terminal project will have no impact on the area’s schools.
The school board filed its lawsuit November 3 against the Army Corps and William H. Graham Jr., the commanding general, in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana.
At issue is the Louisiana International Terminal, a planned deepwater container terminal project on the Lower Mississippi River in Violet in St. Bernard Parish.
The defendants decided to issue a permit under Section 404 of the federal Clean Water Act and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act to the Board of Commissioners of the Port of New Orleans.
The permit authorizes construction of the terminal. Specifically, the permit authorizes the filling of wetlands and the placement of structures in U.S. waters.
According to the 33-page complaint, the permit is a “necessary prerequisite” for the construction of the facility.
Construction of the terminal would include clearing, dredging, excavating, fill deposition, and grading activities.
According to the suit, the terminal would permanently impact 416.4 acres of jurisdictional wetlands and temporarily impact up to 388 acres of non-vegetated water bottoms in the Mississippi River.
Construction is planned to occur in three main phases over the next 30 years or more.
“Because permitting the construction of the Louisiana International Terminal is a major federal action, the National Environmental Policy Act requires the Corps to consider the environmental impacts, broadly construed, of the project before issuing a permit,” the complaint states.
“To satisfy this requirement, the Corps conducted an Environmental Assessment.”
An environmental assessment is called for when it is clear that a project will have no significant impact or when it is unknown whether a permit would have a significant impact.
The conclusion of the assessment was that the construction of the terminal would have no significant impact on the environment and community.
The school board, in its lawsuit, challenges the legality of the assessment, its conclusion, and the permit based upon it.
“Of particular concern to the School Board, the construction of the Louisiana International Terminal will occur in phases over decades, at first surrounding the W. Smith Jr. Elementary School and finally, if completed as planned, destroying the school to build out terminal components on top of its current location,” the suit states.
The school board contends the Corps’ approval of the terminal without preparing an Environmental Impact Statement, without an adequate assessment, without prerequisite authorities, and without “adequate attention” to the environmental impacts violates the federal Administrative Procedure Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, and the Clean Water Act.
“The St. Bernard Parish School Board reasonably anticipates that the safety, health, and welfare of the students, teachers, and other employees of W. Smith Jr. Elementary School will be significantly harmed by the construction and encirclement of the massive Ultra Large Container Vessel terminal facility known as the Louisiana International Terminal,” its complaint states.
“Further, St. Bernard Parish School Board reasonably anticipates that efforts and measures aimed at lessening the significant impacts will cause it economic expense and hardship.”
The school board requests declaratory and injunctive relief vacating the Corps’ approval of the permit and enjoining the permit until all legal requirements have been satisfied.
