City Hall, Anaheim, California
ANAHEIM — The city of Anaheim and plaintiffs who sued the city over allegations of civil rights and sexual harassment violations at city-funded homeless shelters have agreed to a settlement that puts new policies in place homeless advocates say will protect the rights of shelter residents and allow the homeless greater freedom of movement within the city.
The agreement was signed by plaintiffs Cyndi Utzman, Wendy Powitzky and Catherine Moore, as well as representatives of the ACLU Foundation of Southern California and Oma’s Angel Foundation earlier this month. The Anaheim City Council approved the settlement on Nov. 10, resolving issues outlined in a lawsuit filed in Orange County Superior Court.
“The suit followed a 2019 ACLU SoCal investigative report exposing widespread sexual harassment of women in Orange County shelters, including invasive body searches, unwanted touching, lewd propositions and voyeurism by staff members,” the ACLU said in a news release. “The report also documented rodent and bedbug infestations, filthy broken toilets and showers left unrepaired and extreme temperatures.”
The agreement puts in place a policy allowing homeless people to walk or bike between city-funded homeless shelters. A previous policy required shelter residents without a car to use designated transportation rather than come and go at will, according to the ACLU, which said the policy was intended to keep residents out of view of nearby residents.
Residents who enter the Anaheim Emergency Shelter are also protected against manual pat-down searches without reasonable justification under the new policy, according to the agreement. In addition, the city and parties to the agreement have agreed to enforce a zero-tolerance policy for sexual harassment at city-funded shelters and to ensure than staff receive training in sexual harassment prevention.
The settlement also includes a payment – whose amount was not disclosed – from the Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co. to the ACLU Foundation of Southern California's Claim-Trust Account. The ACLU did not respond to a request for comment about payment details.
The settlement, however, indicates that although the parties have agreed to bear their own attorney fees and costs of the litigation, a portion of the payment to the ACLU account may be allocated to attorney fees. A spokesman for the city of Anaheim stressed the city did not pay out any monetary amount as a result of the settlement.
“There are times when putting a disputed claim behind us is best, and that’s the case here,” Mike Lyster, the city’s chief communications officer, told the Southern California Record in an email. “The issues raised involved a shelter that operated from 2019 to 2022. We welcome the best practices outlined, and they have been, and continue to be, standard at our ongoing 325-bed Anaheim Emergency Shelter.”
The city will continue to offer shuttle transportation for shelter residents for work, health care and other outings, according to Lyster, “with residents free to go out on their own.”
Minouche Kandel, senior staff attorney with the ACLU of Southern California, said the ACLU’s clients spent six years battling policies he said robbed the homeless of their self-respect.
“This settlement is an important milestone, but we are not done,” Kandel said in a prepared statement. “We hope Orange County can also agree to not violate the constitutional rights of our unhoused neighbors. Everyone deserves safe, stable housing, not shelters that violate their basic rights.”
The ACLU indicated that despite the Anaheim settlement, litigation against Orange County and other defendants will continue until they agree to further policy changes regarding homeless shelters the ACLU asserts are yet needed to further protect their rights.
