School.jpg

CHARLESTON — State officials are asking the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals to consider limiting a landmark school funding ruling, while Lincoln County school officials acknowledge the state’s funding formula falls short but say they cannot be ordered to fix it.

In a brief filed November 20, attorneys for House Speaker Roger Hanshaw (R-Clay), Senate President Randy Smith (R-Preston) and other state respondents urged the justices to reject a Lincoln County student’s petition challenging public school funding. If the court finds its 1979 decision in Pauley v. Kelly authorizes the relief sought, the officials want the justices to partially overrule it.

The request would limit courts’ authority to enforce constitutional standards for the quality and adequacy of public schools, leaving those judgments to the Legislature. The state officers argue courts could still enforce specific constitutional restrictions, including prohibitions on discriminatory classifications in school financing.

The filing came a day after American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia attorneys representing the student urged the court to reject the state officers’ previously filed motion to dismiss, arguing lawmakers cannot shield themselves from judicial review of their constitutional duties.

The Lincoln County Board of Education separately asked the court to deny relief against it, even as it agreed the state formula does not adequately meet the county’s needs.

“That funding falls short,” the board’s response states. “The formula turns largely on enrollment and does little to meet the added costs of educating Lincoln County’s students.”

November 20 was the deadline for respondents to submit briefs or summary responses to the petition. Separate motions to dismiss the case and hold it in abeyance remained pending.

The case was brought by a Lincoln County sixth grader identified as M.D., through her mother, Lakin Patten. The petition challenges whether school conditions and funding in Lincoln County and statewide satisfy the West Virginia Constitution’s requirement that the Legislature provide a “thorough and efficient system of free schools.”

The student seeks a writ of mandamus compelling officials to meet their constitutional obligations, declarations that the school financing system is unconstitutional and attorney fees.

In their latest response, attorneys from Attorney General J.B. McCuskey’s office argued that the history of the Pauley litigation demonstrates the limits of court-directed education reform. That litigation began with Lincoln County parents in 1975 and continued through decades of proceedings over funding and educational standards.

“The court shouldn’t accept petitioner’s invitation to repeat Pauley’s failed experiment,” the state officers’ brief states.

Their alternative request targets Syllabus Point 5 of Pauley, which requires the Legislature to develop a high-quality statewide education system, and the decision’s accompanying definition of a thorough and efficient system. They ask the court to overrule those portions to the extent they make school quality or adequacy a judicially enforceable standard.

The officials first ask the justices to decline to hear the petition in the court’s original jurisdiction, arguing disputed evidence about funding, student performance and the causes of educational deficiencies belongs in circuit court. Alternatively, they ask the court to deny the writ.

Their brief also disputes the petition’s characterization of school funding. It says Lincoln County receives $7,741.80 in basic state aid per pupil for the 2026-27 school year, the highest amount among the counties and about 31% above the statewide average. The officials argue the formula directs additional state support to counties with less local property wealth.

The response acknowledges West Virginia’s academic performance remains below national averages but cites gains following pandemic-era declines. It also points to ongoing work on funding changes, including a House-commissioned RAND study, draft legislation prepared by the Department of Education and a November legislative hearing.

The ACLU’s November 19 response addresses the state officers’ earlier dismissal motion, which raised legislative immunity and challenged M.D.’s standing to sue.

“Rarely does a procedural argument rise to the level of a constitutional coup,” attorneys Aubrey Sparks and Robb Livingood wrote in the filing’s opening.

They argue that statutes protecting lawmakers cannot override the court’s constitutional authority to determine whether the Legislature has fulfilled its obligation to fund public education.

“If the arguments of the state officer respondents prevail, the Legislature will have held itself to be the final arbiter of our Constitution, then used that self-proclaimed authority to insulate itself from judicial review,” the response states.

The attorneys also contend the state’s position conflicts with arguments it made while defending the Hope Scholarship Act in State v. Beaver in 2022. According to their filing, the state argued then that parents could bring a challenge under Pauley if lawmakers failed to adequately fund public schools.

The current case follows that approach and does not challenge the Hope Scholarship Act, they argue. They also cite Pauley’s direction that the House speaker and Senate president be added as defendants in that litigation.

Addressing standing, the ACLU response provides additional allegations about M.D.’s educational experience. It says Patten sought remedial services, tutoring and other assistance for her daughter but encountered school employees who wanted to help and lacked sufficient resources.

Remedial math programs were unavailable at M.D.’s school, and teachers had little availability to provide additional support, the filing alleges. Her attorneys argue those circumstances establish an individual injury, separate from their argument that her citizenship allows her to seek enforcement of a public duty.

The county school board’s response, meanwhile, distinguishes between acknowledging inadequate funding and accepting responsibility for changing it.

The Legislature sets levy rates, writes the formula and determines staffing allowances, the board argues. County officials cannot change those decisions, and the petition identifies no required act the board has failed to perform.

“Petitioner asks this court to compel the Lincoln County Board of Education to do what she admits it already does,” the response begins, citing the petition’s acknowledgment that county schools have continued operating to the best of their ability within available funding.

The board also points to findings from the earlier Pauley litigation that Lincoln County school officials were operating efficiently within their financial constraints. It argues the current petition identifies no inefficiency or statutory violation that would justify a writ against the board.

Although it agrees the formula falls short, the board does not ask the justices to declare the statewide system unconstitutional on the existing record. Any surviving claim should proceed in circuit court, where experts could testify and evidence could be tested through cross-examination, its attorneys argue.

Steptoe & Johnson attorneys Colton Parsons, Mattie Shuler and Daniel Boothe filed the response for the board, its members and Superintendent Frank Barnett.

The Lincoln County Commission and Commissioners Phoebe Harless, Kim Blair and Josh Stowers took no position on the petition’s constitutional questions. Their November 19 summary response says they do not join any other party’s arguments on the merits.

The commission also said its neutrality should not be treated as an admission of wrongdoing or consent to relief, attorney fees or costs.

West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals case number 26-597

More News