judge-striking-gavel-on-wooden-block.png

A judge holds a gavel above a block in a courtroom.

CHARLESTON, S.C. - The judge overseeing thousands of lawsuits over firefighting foam containing PFAS “forever chemicals” ordered more than 400 cases dismissed after plaintiffs couldn’t come up with medical records to support their claims.

Saying the normal practice is for plaintiffs to collect their medical records before filing suit, Judge Richard Gergel recently approved a magistrate judge’s recommendation to dismiss cases with no records without prejudice. Plaintiff attorneys Napoli Shkolnik argued they needed more time before the court applied the “drastic remedy” of denying their clients their day in court.

“These Plaintiffs have litigated in good faith and stand ready to participate in discovery to ascertain the full extent of their injuries,” Napoli Shkolnik said in an October filing. “The mere fact that they have not yet been able to produce medical records does not reflect a lack of merit to their claims.”

Judge Gergel was unmoved, saying plaintiff lawyers offered no rebuttal to the magistrate judge’s analysis that “typically, this information is gathered prior to the filing of a complaint.” The “alternatives” proposed by lawyers “would subvert the orderly administration” of multidistrict litigation over the foam, which allegedly leached into groundwater and causes a variety of illnesses.

Among the plaintiffs whose cases were dismissed were one who said she suffered from thyroid cancer and another with ulcerative colitis, neither of whom submitted medical records after more than two years’ notice they were required.

Multidistrict litigation involves hundreds or thousands of individual lawsuits that are gathered in a single court for pretrial administration and, typically, a global settlement. Plaintiff lawyers spent tens of millions of dollars advertising for PFAS claimants in order to present such a large body of cases that defendants - who include 3M, Bayer and other chemical companies - are forced to settle.

To level the playing field, MDL judges increasingly require plaintiffs to submit questionnaires with basic information to support their claims, such as medical records and details about where and when they were exposed to the product they are suing over. 

Judge Gergel set up that process early in the PFAS MDL, which once held more than 20,000 lawsuits claiming injury from the long-lasting chemicals found in firefighting foam and numerous products. 

But in a February order, the judge tightened the deadlines for compliance, allowing the defendants to move to dismiss mass numbers of cases lacking documentation. The defendants initially sought to dismiss 18,000 cases, a number that has steadily dropped as lawyers submitted records or got their clients to drop out of the litigation. In his Nov. 16 order, Judge Gergel ruled more than 400 cases will be dismissed immediately.

Critics of the MDL process say it gives plaintiff lawyers an incentive to advertise for large numbers of clients, even if they lack the capacity to represent all of them on an individual basis. In this case, lawyers admitted they were unable to even contact some of the clients they had signed up, making it impossible to obtain their medical records.

There are different types of plaintiffs in the MDL. In addition to private individuals, public water systems have alleged damages and scored huge settlements. BASF paid $316.5 million, Tyco $750 million, DuPont $1.2 billion and 3M 10.5 billion.

More News